Free US Shipping on Orders Over $49.
Use code ST49SHIP
  1. baseball Memorabilia
  2. American League
  3. American League Trading Cards
  4. American League Singles Trading Cards
Trading Cards
1 - 72 of 9000
...
9000 Items9000 Items
1996 Topps Series 2 Baseball 17-Card Retail Pack Mickey Mantle Refractors
$21.99
1996 Topps Series 2 Baseball 17-Card Retail Pack Mickey Mantle Refractors
Almost Gone
1969 Topps #510 Rod Carew Minnesota Twins Baseball Card VG app w/c READ
$24.99
1969 Topps #510 Rod Carew Minnesota Twins Baseball Card VG app w/c READ
Almost Gone
1969 Topps #311 Sparky Lyle Boston Red Sox Rookie Baseball Card EX
$19.99
1969 Topps #311 Sparky Lyle Boston Red Sox Rookie Baseball Card EX
Almost Gone
Gerrit Cole 2025 Topps Allen & Ginter Jersey Card #AGR-GC
$24.99
Gerrit Cole 2025 Topps Allen & Ginter Jersey Card #AGR-GC
Almost Gone
Bobby Witt Jr. 2022 Topps International Trading Card Day RC #NTCD-13
$24.99
Bobby Witt Jr. 2022 Topps International Trading Card Day RC #NTCD-13
Almost Gone
Joe Pepitone 1967 Topps Card #340
$24.99
Joe Pepitone 1967 Topps Card #340
Almost Gone
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. 2025 Topps Bat Relic Card #T90R-VG
$24.99
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. 2025 Topps Bat Relic Card #T90R-VG
Almost Gone
Boog Powell 1967 Topps Card #230
$24.99
Boog Powell 1967 Topps Card #230
Almost Gone
Reggie Jackson 1977 Topps Card #10
$24.99
Reggie Jackson 1977 Topps Card #10
Almost Gone
Derek Jeter 2002 Topps Finest Card #14
$24.99
Derek Jeter 2002 Topps Finest Card #14
Almost Gone
Bob Shirley autographed baseball card (New York Yankees) 1984 Topps #684
$21.99
Bob Shirley autographed baseball card (New York Yankees) 1984 Topps #684
Bob Shirley autographed baseball card (New York Yankees) 1985 Topps #328
$21.99
Bob Shirley autographed baseball card (New York Yankees) 1985 Topps #328
Matt Lindstrom autographed baseball card (New York Mets FT) 2006 Topps Bowman #FG41
$21.99
Matt Lindstrom autographed baseball card (New York Mets FT) 2006 Topps Bowman #FG41
Almost Gone
Billy Sample autographed baseball card (New York Yankees) 1986 Topps #533
$21.99
Billy Sample autographed baseball card (New York Yankees) 1986 Topps #533
Almost Gone
Ron Davis autographed baseball card (New York Yankees) 1982 Donruss #451
$24.99
Ron Davis autographed baseball card (New York Yankees) 1982 Donruss #451
Almost Gone
1987 Topps #340 Roger Clemens Red Sox Psa 9
$23.99
1987 Topps #340 Roger Clemens Red Sox Psa 9
Almost Gone
Mickey Mantle 1996 Topps #7 Reprint Card
$24.99
Mickey Mantle 1996 Topps #7 Reprint Card
Almost Gone
Ken Griffey Jr Unsigned 1989 Donruss Rated Rookie Card
$24.99
Ken Griffey Jr Unsigned 1989 Donruss Rated Rookie Card
Almost Gone
Austin Martin 2025 TOPPS SERIES TWO 41/50 Card #595 TWINS
$23.99
Austin Martin 2025 TOPPS SERIES TWO 41/50 Card #595 TWINS
Almost Gone
Bob Shirley autographed baseball card (New York Yankees) 1987 Topps #524
$21.99
Bob Shirley autographed baseball card (New York Yankees) 1987 Topps #524
Almost Gone
Mickey Rivers autographed Baseball Card (Texas Rangers) 1984 Topps #504
$23.99
Mickey Rivers autographed Baseball Card (Texas Rangers) 1984 Topps #504
Almost Gone
Bob Shirley autographed baseball card (New York Yankees) 1986 Topps #213
$21.99
Bob Shirley autographed baseball card (New York Yankees) 1986 Topps #213
Almost Gone
David Huff autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 2010 Topps Heritage #18
$21.99
David Huff autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 2010 Topps Heritage #18
Almost Gone
Indians Justin Masterson Signed 2010 Bowman Gold Autograph Card #141 TOUGH 113
$23.99
Indians Justin Masterson Signed 2010 Bowman Gold Autograph Card #141 TOUGH 113
Almost Gone
George Vikovich autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1985 Donruss #276
$21.99
George Vikovich autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1985 Donruss #276
Almost Gone
Jerry Willard autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1985 Fleer #460
$24.99
Jerry Willard autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1985 Fleer #460
Almost Gone
Enrique Wilson Kinston Indians - Indians Affiliate 1995 Upper Deck SP Top Prospects Die Cast Autographed Card - Minor League Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
$21.99
Enrique Wilson Kinston Indians - Indians Affiliate 1995 Upper Deck SP Top Prospects Die Cast Autographed Card - Minor League Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
Almost Gone
Doc Edwards autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1988 Topps #374
$24.99
Doc Edwards autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1988 Topps #374
Almost Gone
David Riske autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1999 Fleer Tradition #U-53
$21.99
David Riske autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1999 Fleer Tradition #U-53
Almost Gone
Mike Fischlin Cleveland Indians 1983 Fleer Autographed Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
$21.99
Mike Fischlin Cleveland Indians 1983 Fleer Autographed Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
Almost Gone
Corey Smith Cleveland Indians 2000 Bowman Chrome Autographed Card - Rookie Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
$21.99
Corey Smith Cleveland Indians 2000 Bowman Chrome Autographed Card - Rookie Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
Almost Gone
Cleveland Indians Casey Blake Signed 2004 Bowman Autograph Card #51 TOUGH 113
$23.99
Cleveland Indians Casey Blake Signed 2004 Bowman Autograph Card #51 TOUGH 113
Almost Gone
Rick Manning autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1980 Topps #564
$24.99
Rick Manning autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1980 Topps #564
Almost Gone
Jaret Wright autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1994 Upper Deck Draft Class #221
$21.99
Jaret Wright autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1994 Upper Deck Draft Class #221
Almost Gone
Andre Thornton autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1982 Topps #746
$24.99
Andre Thornton autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1982 Topps #746
Almost Gone
Rich Thompson autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1986 Topps #242
$21.99
Rich Thompson autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1986 Topps #242
Almost Gone
Cliff Bartosh autographed Baseball Card (San Diego Padres) 2002 Topps #T146
$21.99
Cliff Bartosh autographed Baseball Card (San Diego Padres) 2002 Topps #T146
Almost Gone
Sal Fasano Wilmington Blue Rocks - Royals Affiliate 1995 Upper Deck Autographed Card - Minor League Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
$21.99
Sal Fasano Wilmington Blue Rocks - Royals Affiliate 1995 Upper Deck Autographed Card - Minor League Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
Almost Gone
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians 1993 Leaf Autographed Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
$21.99
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians 1993 Leaf Autographed Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
Almost Gone
David Miller autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1996 Bowman Rookie #329
$21.99
David Miller autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1996 Bowman Rookie #329
Almost Gone
Tom Candiotti autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1989 Topps #599
$24.99
Tom Candiotti autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1989 Topps #599
Almost Gone
Josh Bard autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 2003 Fleer Platinum #41
$24.99
Josh Bard autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 2003 Fleer Platinum #41
Almost Gone
Tony Sipp autographed baseball card (Cleveland Indians) 2011 Topps #536
$21.99
Tony Sipp autographed baseball card (Cleveland Indians) 2011 Topps #536
Almost Gone
Rick Waits autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1981 Donruss #201
$21.99
Rick Waits autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1981 Donruss #201
Almost Gone
Bill Glynn autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1953 Topps Archive #171
$23.99
Bill Glynn autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1953 Topps Archive #171
Almost Gone
Jaret Wright autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1998 Topps Gallery #38
$21.99
Jaret Wright autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1998 Topps Gallery #38
Almost Gone
Frank Duffy autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1976 Topps #232
$21.99
Frank Duffy autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1976 Topps #232
Almost Gone
Todd Hollandsworth San Antonio Missions - Dodgers Affiliate 1993 Upper Deck SP Top Prospects Autographed Card - Minor League Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
$21.99
Todd Hollandsworth San Antonio Missions - Dodgers Affiliate 1993 Upper Deck SP Top Prospects Autographed Card - Minor League Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
Almost Gone
1960 Topps #122 Don Dillard Indians Signed Rookie Auto 15a
$23.99
1960 Topps #122 Don Dillard Indians Signed Rookie Auto 15a
Almost Gone
Jason Anderson Staten Island Yankees - Yankees Affiliate 2002 Bowman Autographed Card - Minor League Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
$21.99
Jason Anderson Staten Island Yankees - Yankees Affiliate 2002 Bowman Autographed Card - Minor League Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
Almost Gone
Duane Kuiper autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians, FT) 1982 Donruss #198
$24.99
Duane Kuiper autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians, FT) 1982 Donruss #198
Almost Gone
Steve Kline autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1997 Upper Deck CC #315
$24.99
Steve Kline autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1997 Upper Deck CC #315
Almost Gone
Mark Whiten autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1991 Donruss #32
$24.99
Mark Whiten autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1991 Donruss #32
Almost Gone
Chad Ogea Charlotte Knights - Indians Affiliate 1993 Upper Deck SP Top Prospects Autographed Card - Minor League Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
$21.99
Chad Ogea Charlotte Knights - Indians Affiliate 1993 Upper Deck SP Top Prospects Autographed Card - Minor League Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
Almost Gone
Jeremy Guthrie autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians, FT) 2002 Donruss The Rookies #69
$21.99
Jeremy Guthrie autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians, FT) 2002 Donruss The Rookies #69
Almost Gone
Jim Landis autographed baseball card (Cleveland Indians) 1966 Topps #128
$24.99
Jim Landis autographed baseball card (Cleveland Indians) 1966 Topps #128
Almost Gone
Zach McAllister autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 2013 Topps #513
$24.99
Zach McAllister autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 2013 Topps #513
Almost Gone
Al Smith Card 1964 Topps #317 PSA 4
$21.99
Al Smith Card 1964 Topps #317 PSA 4
Almost Gone
Jeff Liefer Birmingham Barons - White Sox Affiliate 1997 Upper Deck SP Top Prospects Autographed Card - Minor League Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
$21.99
Jeff Liefer Birmingham Barons - White Sox Affiliate 1997 Upper Deck SP Top Prospects Autographed Card - Minor League Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
Almost Gone
Andre Thornton autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1985 Fleer #457
$24.99
Andre Thornton autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1985 Fleer #457
Almost Gone
Tom Brennan autographed baseball card (Cleveland Indians) 1983 Fleer #403
$21.99
Tom Brennan autographed baseball card (Cleveland Indians) 1983 Fleer #403
Almost Gone
Graded EXMT/EXMT+
$21.99
Graded EXMT/EXMT+
Almost Gone
Dermal Brown Spokane Indians - Royals Affiliate 1998 Bowman Autographed Card - Minor League Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
$21.99
Dermal Brown Spokane Indians - Royals Affiliate 1998 Bowman Autographed Card - Minor League Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
Almost Gone
Jason Michaels autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 2008 Topps #63
$21.99
Jason Michaels autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 2008 Topps #63
Almost Gone
Bryan Oelkers Indians 1987 Topps #77 Twins Signed Authentic Autograph JA15
$23.99
Bryan Oelkers Indians 1987 Topps #77 Twins Signed Authentic Autograph JA15
Almost Gone
Chad Durbin Wichita Wranglers - Royals Affiliate 2000 Topps Rookie Autographed Card - Minor League Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
$21.99
Chad Durbin Wichita Wranglers - Royals Affiliate 2000 Topps Rookie Autographed Card - Minor League Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
Almost Gone
Mark Lewis Cleveland Indians 1993 Donruss Autographed Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
$21.99
Mark Lewis Cleveland Indians 1993 Donruss Autographed Card. This item comes with a certificate of authenticity from Autograph-Sports. Autographed
Almost Gone
Jaret Wright autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1998 Upper Deck CC #SQ27
$21.99
Jaret Wright autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1998 Upper Deck CC #SQ27
Almost Gone
Brett Butler Indians 1987 Topps #723 Braves Signed Authentic Autograph JA15
$23.99
Brett Butler Indians 1987 Topps #723 Braves Signed Authentic Autograph JA15
Almost Gone
Brad Komminsk autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1989 Fleer #U-28
$24.99
Brad Komminsk autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1989 Fleer #U-28
Almost Gone
Tom Candiotti autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1987 Donruss #342
$24.99
Tom Candiotti autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1987 Donruss #342
Almost Gone
Chad Ogea autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1995 Upper Deck CC #7
$21.99
Chad Ogea autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1995 Upper Deck CC #7
Almost Gone
...