Free US Shipping on Orders Over $49.
Use code ST49SHIP
  1. baseball Memorabilia
  2. American League
  3. American League Trading Cards
Trading Cards
1 - 72 of 9000
...
9000 Items9000 Items
PSA 10 Bobby Witt Jr. 2022 Topps Now #21 Acrobatic Stop/Throw Rookie Card
$126.99
PSA 10 Bobby Witt Jr. 2022 Topps Now #21 Acrobatic Stop/Throw Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Aaron Judge Rookie Card 2013 Bowman Draft Picks Prospects #BDPP19 PSA 9
$308.99
Aaron Judge Rookie Card 2013 Bowman Draft Picks Prospects #BDPP19 PSA 9
Ships Free
Almost Gone
PSA 10 Angel Reese 2024 Panini Instant #RRR2 Rated Rookie Retro Rookie Card
$126.99
PSA 10 Angel Reese 2024 Panini Instant #RRR2 Rated Rookie Retro Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Derek Jeter Rookie Card 1993 Pinnacle #457 PSA 9
$138.99
Derek Jeter Rookie Card 1993 Pinnacle #457 PSA 9
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Carl Yastrzemski Signed 1969 Topps #130 Red Sox Auto HOF 89 Inscription PSA/DNA
$463.99
Carl Yastrzemski Signed 1969 Topps #130 Red Sox Auto HOF 89 Inscription PSA/DNA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1993 Bowman #511 Derek Jeter Yankees Rookie PSA 9 MINT
$269.99
1993 Bowman #511 Derek Jeter Yankees Rookie PSA 9 MINT
Ships Free
Almost Gone
PSA 10 Wyatt Langford 2023 Bowman Draft #BD106 1st Rookie Card
$126.99
PSA 10 Wyatt Langford 2023 Bowman Draft #BD106 1st Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1990 Topps #336 Ken Griffey Jr. All-Star Rookie PSA 9 Graded Baseball Card MLB
$83.99
1990 Topps #336 Ken Griffey Jr. All-Star Rookie PSA 9 Graded Baseball Card MLB
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Derek Jeter Card 2013 Topps Emerald #373 PSA 10
$231.99
Derek Jeter Card 2013 Topps Emerald #373 PSA 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
BO JACKSON KANSAS CITY Royals Signed 1987 DONRUSS RC Rookie Card PSA 85510368
$617.99
BO JACKSON KANSAS CITY Royals Signed 1987 DONRUSS RC Rookie Card PSA 85510368
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Shohei Ohtani Rookie Card 2018 Panini Diamond Kings #76 PSA 9
$154.99
Shohei Ohtani Rookie Card 2018 Panini Diamond Kings #76 PSA 9
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Aaron Judge Rookie Card 2014 Bowman Draft Picks Chrome #CTP39 PSA 9
$123.99
Aaron Judge Rookie Card 2014 Bowman Draft Picks Chrome #CTP39 PSA 9
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Alex Rodriguez Rookie Card 1994 SP #15 PSA 8
$86.99
Alex Rodriguez Rookie Card 1994 SP #15 PSA 8
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1996 Topps #228 Mike Mussina Orioles Hof Psa 10
$119.99
1996 Topps #228 Mike Mussina Orioles Hof Psa 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1987 Topps #784 Cal Ripken Jr. Orioles Hof Psa 9
$31.99
1987 Topps #784 Cal Ripken Jr. Orioles Hof Psa 9
Almost Gone
2012 Topps #30 Derek Jeter Yankees Hof Psa 9
$35.99
2012 Topps #30 Derek Jeter Yankees Hof Psa 9
Almost Gone
2010 Topps Attax Code Card Justin Verlander Tigers Pop 2 Psa 9
$35.99
2010 Topps Attax Code Card Justin Verlander Tigers Pop 2 Psa 9
Almost Gone
2022 Topps #27 Mike Trout Angels Psa 9
$35.99
2022 Topps #27 Mike Trout Angels Psa 9
Almost Gone
2006 Topps #460 Randy Johnson Yankees Hof Pop 6 Psa 9
$35.99
2006 Topps #460 Randy Johnson Yankees Hof Pop 6 Psa 9
Almost Gone
1995 Topps #519 Kirk Gibson Tigers Pop 6 Psa 9
$35.99
1995 Topps #519 Kirk Gibson Tigers Pop 6 Psa 9
Almost Gone
1994 Topps #410 Lou Whitaker Tigers Psa 9
$35.99
1994 Topps #410 Lou Whitaker Tigers Psa 9
Almost Gone
1990 Topps #97 Curt Schilling Ftc Orioles Psa 9
$35.99
1990 Topps #97 Curt Schilling Ftc Orioles Psa 9
Almost Gone
1992 Topps #570 Lou Whitaker Tigers Psa 9
$35.99
1992 Topps #570 Lou Whitaker Tigers Psa 9
Almost Gone
1990 Topps #760 Wade Boggs Red Sox Hof Psa 9
$35.99
1990 Topps #760 Wade Boggs Red Sox Hof Psa 9
Almost Gone
1999 Topps #1 Roger Clemens Blue Jays Psa 9
$35.99
1999 Topps #1 Roger Clemens Blue Jays Psa 9
Almost Gone
2000 Topps #470 Frank Thomas White Sox Hof Pop 5 Psa 9
$35.99
2000 Topps #470 Frank Thomas White Sox Hof Pop 5 Psa 9
Almost Gone
2006 Topps #110 Mariano Rivera Yankees Hof Psa 9
$35.99
2006 Topps #110 Mariano Rivera Yankees Hof Psa 9
Almost Gone
2002 Topps #714 Roger Clemens Yankees Psa 9
$35.99
2002 Topps #714 Roger Clemens Yankees Psa 9
Almost Gone
1998 Topps #265 Randy Johnson Mariners Hof Pop 6 Psa 9
$35.99
1998 Topps #265 Randy Johnson Mariners Hof Pop 6 Psa 9
Almost Gone
1990 Topps #8 Cal Ripken Jr. Orioles Hof Psa 9
$35.99
1990 Topps #8 Cal Ripken Jr. Orioles Hof Psa 9
Almost Gone
1995 Topps #15 Lou Whitaker Tigers Psa 9
$35.99
1995 Topps #15 Lou Whitaker Tigers Psa 9
Almost Gone
1982 Topps #280 John James Falcons Psa 10
$81.99
1982 Topps #280 John James Falcons Psa 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1983 Donruss #4 Jim Palmer AUTO SIGNED Autograph Card PSA/DNA Baseball MLB COA
$113.99
1983 Donruss #4 Jim Palmer AUTO SIGNED Autograph Card PSA/DNA Baseball MLB COA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
PSA Jack Morris Signed 1978 Topps Burger King #8 HOF 2018 RC Detroit Tigers
$576.99
PSA Jack Morris Signed 1978 Topps Burger King #8 HOF 2018 RC Detroit Tigers
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2017 Topps Archives Dark Jacket Dard Hat Babe Ruth Card Yankees Psa 10 Low Pop
$817.99
2017 Topps Archives Dark Jacket Dard Hat Babe Ruth Card Yankees Psa 10 Low Pop
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Jesse Jefferson Autographed 1977 Topps Card #326 Toronto Blue Jays PSA/DNA #83306527
$28.99
Jesse Jefferson Autographed 1977 Topps Card #326 Toronto Blue Jays PSA/DNA #83306527
Almost Gone
Jesse Jefferson Autographed 1977 Topps Card #326 Toronto Blue Jays PSA/DNA #83306526
$28.99
Jesse Jefferson Autographed 1977 Topps Card #326 Toronto Blue Jays PSA/DNA #83306526
Almost Gone
Aaron Judge Card 2021 Topps #99 PSA 8
$28.99
Aaron Judge Card 2021 Topps #99 PSA 8
Almost Gone
Jonatan Clase Rookie 2022 Bowman Chrome Pros Refractor (425/499) #BCP118 PSA 10
$35.99
Jonatan Clase Rookie 2022 Bowman Chrome Pros Refractor (425/499) #BCP118 PSA 10
Almost Gone
Aaron Judge Card 2025 Topps Chrome Fortunte 15 #F15-1 PSA 8
$43.99
Aaron Judge Card 2025 Topps Chrome Fortunte 15 #F15-1 PSA 8
Almost Gone
Josh Jung Rookie Card 2023 Bowman Spotlights #Bs18 PSA 9
$35.99
Josh Jung Rookie Card 2023 Bowman Spotlights #Bs18 PSA 9
Almost Gone
1972 Topps #266 Bobby Bolin Red Sox Psa 8
$44.99
1972 Topps #266 Bobby Bolin Red Sox Psa 8
Almost Gone
2010 Topps #637 Babe Ruth-lou Gehrig Yankees Hof Psa 9
$44.99
2010 Topps #637 Babe Ruth-lou Gehrig Yankees Hof Psa 9
Almost Gone
1999 Topps #95 Pedro Martinez Red Sox Hof Psa 9
$44.99
1999 Topps #95 Pedro Martinez Red Sox Hof Psa 9
Almost Gone
1972 TOPPS #352 DAVE LaROCHE TWINS PSA 8.5
$44.99
1972 TOPPS #352 DAVE LaROCHE TWINS PSA 8.5
Almost Gone
1982 Topps #300 Reggie Jackson Yankees Hof Psa 8
$44.99
1982 Topps #300 Reggie Jackson Yankees Hof Psa 8
Almost Gone
Frank Thomas Autographed 1990 Topps Rookie Card #414 Chicago White Sox PSA 10 Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 PSA/DNA #111292546
$1,311.99
Frank Thomas Autographed 1990 Topps Rookie Card #414 Chicago White Sox PSA 10 Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 PSA/DNA #111292546
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2016 Topps Museum Collection Ken Griffey Jr. Gold Framed Auto #15/15 PSA 8
$2,901.99
2016 Topps Museum Collection Ken Griffey Jr. Gold Framed Auto #15/15 PSA 8
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2021 Topps Allen & Ginter Chrome Mini #147 George Brett Card Royals Psa 10 Rare
$363.99
2021 Topps Allen & Ginter Chrome Mini #147 George Brett Card Royals Psa 10 Rare
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Cody Bellinger Rookie Card 2017 Topps Heritage #678 PSA 9
$35.99
Cody Bellinger Rookie Card 2017 Topps Heritage #678 PSA 9
Almost Gone
Elier Hernandez Rookie Card 2023 Topps Update #US304 PSA 10
$28.99
Elier Hernandez Rookie Card 2023 Topps Update #US304 PSA 10
Almost Gone
Gleyber Torres Card 2020 Topps Gypsy Queen Fortune Tellers Mini #10 PSA 9
$28.99
Gleyber Torres Card 2020 Topps Gypsy Queen Fortune Tellers Mini #10 PSA 9
Almost Gone
2016 Topps National Baseball Card Day #43 Ichiro Suzuki Hof Pop 1 Psa 9
$39.99
2016 Topps National Baseball Card Day #43 Ichiro Suzuki Hof Pop 1 Psa 9
Almost Gone
1999 Topps #454 Sammy Sosa-ken Griffey Jr.-juan Gonzalez Psa 9
$32.99
1999 Topps #454 Sammy Sosa-ken Griffey Jr.-juan Gonzalez Psa 9
Almost Gone
2005 Topps #565 Roger Clemens Astros Psa 9
$32.99
2005 Topps #565 Roger Clemens Astros Psa 9
Almost Gone
1963 TOPPS #348 VIC WERTZ Tigers PSA 6
$52.99
1963 TOPPS #348 VIC WERTZ Tigers PSA 6
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2023 Topps #17 Shohei Ohtani Angels Psa 10
$156.99
2023 Topps #17 Shohei Ohtani Angels Psa 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Bob Grim Card 1975 Topps #173 PSA 8
$35.99
Bob Grim Card 1975 Topps #173 PSA 8
Almost Gone
Justin Foscue Rookie Card 2024 Topps Heritage Real One Autograph #ROAJU PSA 9
$35.99
Justin Foscue Rookie Card 2024 Topps Heritage Real One Autograph #ROAJU PSA 9
Almost Gone
Manny Ramirez Rookie Card 1992 Bowman Foil #676 PSA 9
$43.99
Manny Ramirez Rookie Card 1992 Bowman Foil #676 PSA 9
Almost Gone
Wyatt Langford Rookie Card 2024 Topps Holiday #H113 PSA 9
$35.99
Wyatt Langford Rookie Card 2024 Topps Holiday #H113 PSA 9
Almost Gone
Mike Trout Card 2020 Topps X Steve Aoki #1 PSA 9
$43.99
Mike Trout Card 2020 Topps X Steve Aoki #1 PSA 9
Almost Gone
Jason Kendall Rookie Card 1993 Stadium Club Murphy #148 PSA 9
$35.99
Jason Kendall Rookie Card 1993 Stadium Club Murphy #148 PSA 9
Almost Gone
Wyatt Langford Rookie Card 2023 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks Prospects #DPP3 PSA 9
$35.99
Wyatt Langford Rookie Card 2023 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks Prospects #DPP3 PSA 9
Almost Gone
1996 Topps #45 Albert Belle Indians Pop 5 Psa 9
$38.99
1996 Topps #45 Albert Belle Indians Pop 5 Psa 9
Almost Gone
2020 Topps #1 Mike Trout Facing Left Psa 9
$38.99
2020 Topps #1 Mike Trout Facing Left Psa 9
Almost Gone
Jackson Kowar Rookie Card 2021 Bowman Next Auto Orange (1/5) #BA59C PSA 9
$50.99
Jackson Kowar Rookie Card 2021 Bowman Next Auto Orange (1/5) #BA59C PSA 9
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Harold Baines Signed 1981 Topps #347 PSA 10 Auto RC Rookie Chicago White Sox
$246.99
Harold Baines Signed 1981 Topps #347 PSA 10 Auto RC Rookie Chicago White Sox
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Jim Abbott Signed 1989 Upper Deck #755 PSA 10 Auto RC Triple Exposure Angels
$388.99
Jim Abbott Signed 1989 Upper Deck #755 PSA 10 Auto RC Triple Exposure Angels
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1981 Topps #480 Carlton Fisk AUTO SIGNED Autograph Card PSA/DNA Baseball MLB COA
$190.99
1981 Topps #480 Carlton Fisk AUTO SIGNED Autograph Card PSA/DNA Baseball MLB COA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Ivan Rodriguez Signed 1991 Donruss Rookies #33 PSA 10 Auto RC HOF Rangers Tigers
$576.99
Ivan Rodriguez Signed 1991 Donruss Rookies #33 PSA 10 Auto RC HOF Rangers Tigers
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2002 eTOPPS CLASSIC TOPPS #ETC18 NOLAN RYAN HOF POP 2 PSA 8
$54.99
2002 eTOPPS CLASSIC TOPPS #ETC18 NOLAN RYAN HOF POP 2 PSA 8
Ships Free
Almost Gone
...