Skip to Main Content
Skip to Filters
Skip to Filters
Skip to Footer
Track my Order
Help
My Account
NFL
MLB
NBA
More
NHL
NCAA
SOCCER
WWE
Display Cases
GAME USED
TRADING CARDS
NEW ARRIVALS
Outlet
NHL
NCAA
SOCCER
More
WWE
Display Cases
GAME USED
TRADING CARDS
NEW ARRIVALS
Outlet
WWE
More Sports
Display Cases
GAME USED
TRADING CARDS
NEW ARRIVALS
Players
Outlet
Free US Shipping on Orders Over $49.
Use code
ST49SHIP
Terms
baseball Memorabilia
American League
American League Trading Cards
American League
Filter & Sort
Cancel
Your Selections
American League
Trading Cards
PSA
1990-1999
Filter By
Signed
Sub Department
Autographed Cards
Autographed Rookie Cards
Rookie Cards
Singles
Athletes
Mike Mussina
Aaron Boone
Adrian Beltre
Al Rosen
Alan Trammell
Alex Rodriguez
Allie Reynolds
Andre Dawson
Andy Pettitte
Bernie Williams
Price Range / Sale
Less than $25
$25 to $50
$50 to $75
$75 to $100
$100 to $150
$150 to $200
$200 to $250
$250 to $300
Over $300
Trading Cards
Filters
1 - 72 of 615
Top Sellers
LowestPrice
HighestPrice
TopSellers
NewestArrivals
72 Items
24
48
72
1
2
3
4
...
9
1
2
3
9
next page
American League
Trading Cards
PSA
1990-1999
615 Items
615 Items
$119.99
1996 Topps #228 Mike Mussina Orioles Hof Psa 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$35.99
1995 Topps #519 Kirk Gibson Tigers Pop 6 Psa 9
Almost Gone
$35.99
1994 Topps #410 Lou Whitaker Tigers Psa 9
Almost Gone
$35.99
1990 Topps #97 Curt Schilling Ftc Orioles Psa 9
Almost Gone
$35.99
1992 Topps #570 Lou Whitaker Tigers Psa 9
Almost Gone
$35.99
1990 Topps #760 Wade Boggs Red Sox Hof Psa 9
Almost Gone
$35.99
1999 Topps #1 Roger Clemens Blue Jays Psa 9
Almost Gone
$35.99
1998 Topps #265 Randy Johnson Mariners Hof Pop 6 Psa 9
Almost Gone
$35.99
1990 Topps #8 Cal Ripken Jr. Orioles Hof Psa 9
Almost Gone
$35.99
1995 Topps #15 Lou Whitaker Tigers Psa 9
Almost Gone
$44.99
1999 Topps #95 Pedro Martinez Red Sox Hof Psa 9
Almost Gone
$1,311.99
Frank Thomas Autographed 1990 Topps Rookie Card #414 Chicago White Sox PSA 10 Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 PSA/DNA #111292546
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$32.99
1999 Topps #454 Sammy Sosa-ken Griffey Jr.-juan Gonzalez Psa 9
Almost Gone
$43.99
Manny Ramirez Rookie Card 1992 Bowman Foil #676 PSA 9
Almost Gone
$35.99
Jason Kendall Rookie Card 1993 Stadium Club Murphy #148 PSA 9
Almost Gone
$38.99
1996 Topps #45 Albert Belle Indians Pop 5 Psa 9
Almost Gone
$576.99
Ivan Rodriguez Signed 1991 Donruss Rookies #33 PSA 10 Auto RC HOF Rangers Tigers
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$120.99
FRANK THOMAS Signed 1990 LEAF Baseball ROOKIE CARD #300 + PSA 707074 Auto 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$74.99
1990 Topps #380 Dave Winfield Yankees Hof Psa 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$138.99
1994 Topps #180 George Brett Royals Hof Psa 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$1,846.99
Frank Thomas Autographed 1990 Leaf Rookie Card #300 Chicago White Sox PSA 10 Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 PSA/DNA #76569010
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$1,846.99
Frank Thomas Autographed 1990 Leaf Rookie Card #300 Chicago White Sox PSA 10 Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 PSA/DNA #76569033
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$1,543.99
Derek Jeter Autographed 1993 Topps Rookie Card #98 New York Yankees Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 PSA/DNA #142287566
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$1,543.99
Ichiro Suzuki Autographed 1993 BBM Rookie Card #239 Orix Blue Wave "#51" In Kanji PSA/DNA #135353442
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$29.99
1991 Topps #600 Bo Jackson Royals Psa 9
Almost Gone
$60.99
FRANK THOMAS Signed 1993 Topps Baseball Card #150 + PSA Auto 04633
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$60.99
FRANK THOMAS Signed 1992 Upper Deck UD Baseball Card #166 + PSA Auto 04632
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$95.99
1994 Ted Williams Co. Willie Wood Green Bay Packers Signed Card Psa Auto 10 7
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$123.99
Derek Jeter Rookie Card 1994 Classic Tampa Yankees #1 PSA 9
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$314.99
1993 Sp #279 Derek Jeter New York Yankees Foil Rookie Baseball Card Psa 5 Ex
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$192.99
Derek Jeter Rookie Card 1992 Front Row Draft Picks Silver #55 PSA 8
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$105.99
1992 JUAN GONZALEZ Signed Upper Deck Baseball Card-TEXAS RANGERS-TIGERS-PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$105.99
1992 JUAN GONZALEZ Signed Donruss Baseball Card-TEXAS RANGERS-TIGERS-PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$86.99
1994 JUAN GONZALEZ Signed Upper Deck Baseball Card-TEXAS RANGERS-TIGERS-PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$149.99
JEFF BAGWELL Houston Astros Signed 1993 Topps Finest Baseball Card PSA Auto 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$388.99
1995 ROGER CLEMENS Signed Card-YANKEES-BLUE JAYS-RED SOX-UPPER DECK-PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$39.99
1992 Donruss #5 Kenny Lofton Rated Rookie Psa 9
Almost Gone
$182.99
Darryl Kile Signed Houston Astros 1993 Topps #308 Card AUTO GRADE GEM MT PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$182.99
Bobby Abreu Signed Astros 1997 Donruss Rookie Card AUTO GRADE GEM MT 10 PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$29.99
1990 Topps #3 Nolan Ryan Angels Hof Psa 9
Almost Gone
$92.99
1994 Topps #480 Albert Belle Indians Psa 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$101.99
1994 Topps #603 Wade Boggs Yankees Hof Psa 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$35.99
1992 Topps #575 Kirby Puckett Twins Hof Psa 9
Almost Gone
$92.99
1994 Topps #606 Ken Griffey Jr. Mariners Hof Psa 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$192.99
1990 Score #663 Frank Thomas RC Rookie HOF PSA 9 PSA/DNA AUTO
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$192.99
Frank Thomas HOF Signed 1992 Donruss #592 Chicago White Sox PSA/DNA AUTO
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$192.99
Frank Thomas HOF Signed 1991 Leaf #281 Chicago White Sox PSA/DNA AUTO
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$50.99
1992 Topps #405 Roger Clemens Red Sox Psa 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$47.99
1995 National Packtime (ud Topps Fleer Pinn. Etc.) #18 Jeff Bagwell Psa 10
Almost Gone
$38.99
1996 Topps #323 Wade Boggs Yankees Hof Psa 9
Almost Gone
$35.99
1992 Topps #400 Cal Ripken Jr. Orioles Hof Psa 9
Almost Gone
$32.99
1992 Topps #10 Wade Boggs Red Sox Hof Psa 9
Almost Gone
$21.99
Jason Giambi Rookie Card 1991 Topps Traded #45T PSA 9
Almost Gone
$101.99
1997 Topps #318 Manny Ramirez Indians Psa 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$21.99
Mike Mussina Card 1997 Topps #375 PSA 6
Almost Gone
$21.99
Eddie Murray Card 1991 Topps #397 PSA 8
Almost Gone
$21.99
Rafael Palmeiro Card 1994 Topps Black Gold #16 PSA 7
Almost Gone
$21.99
Alex Gonzalez Rookie Card 1994 Collector's Choice #8 PSA 8 (scratched holder)
Almost Gone
$21.99
Cal Ripken Jr. Card 1996 Topps #222 PSA 7
Almost Gone
$19.99
PSA 9 MINT Jason Giambi 1991 Topps Traded Card #45T
Almost Gone
$21.99
Rafael Palmeiro Card 1992 Topps Gold #55 PSA 9
Almost Gone
$21.99
Gregg Jefferies Card 1990 Topps #457 PSA 8
Almost Gone
$152.99
Bruce Sutter 1994 Ted Williams Autographed/Signed Card # 18 PSA/DNA BA207513
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$115.99
Curt Schilling PSA DNA Signed 1990 Donruss Rookie Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$69.99
Steve Garvey 1993 Ted Williams Autographed/Signed Card # 14 PSA/DNA BA207512
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$69.99
Steve Garvey 1993 Ted Williams Autographed/Signed Card # 14 PSA/DNA BA207511
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$43.99
Jim Thome Rookie Card 1991 Upper Deck Final Edition #17F PSA 9
Almost Gone
$28.99
Robin Ventura Rookie Card 1990 Upper Deck #21 PSA 9
Almost Gone
$28.99
John Olerud Card 1994 Topps Black Gold #15 PSA 9
Almost Gone
$28.99
Kirby Puckett Card 1990 Topps Tv All-Stars #6 PSA 8
Almost Gone
$28.99
Omar Vizquel Card 1999 Topps #152 PSA 9
Almost Gone
$28.99
Mike Mussina Card 1997 Topps #375 PSA 9
Almost Gone
1
2
3
4
...
9
1
2
3
9
next page