Skip to Main Content
Skip to Filters
Skip to Filters
Skip to Footer
Track my Order
Help
My Account
NFL
MLB
NBA
More
NHL
NCAA
SOCCER
WWE
Display Cases
GAME USED
TRADING CARDS
NEW ARRIVALS
Outlet
NHL
NCAA
SOCCER
More
WWE
Display Cases
GAME USED
TRADING CARDS
NEW ARRIVALS
Outlet
WWE
More Sports
Display Cases
GAME USED
TRADING CARDS
NEW ARRIVALS
Players
Outlet
Free US Shipping on Orders Over $49.
Use code
ST49SHIP
Terms
baseball Memorabilia
American League
American League Trading Cards
American League
Filter & Sort
Cancel
Your Selections
American League
Trading Cards
1990-1999
$250 to $300
Filter By
Signed
Sub Department
Autographed Cards
Rookie Cards
Singles
Authenticator
Beckett
PSA
Schwartz Sports
Upper Deck
Athletes
Bernie Williams
Cal Ripken Jr.
Carlton Fisk
David Ortiz
Derek Jeter
Don Mattingly
Frank Thomas
Harold Baines
Ivan Rodriguez
Jim Edmonds
Trading Cards
Filters
1 - 50 of 50
Top Sellers
LowestPrice
HighestPrice
TopSellers
NewestArrivals
72 Items
24
48
72
American League
Trading Cards
1990-1999
$250 to $300
50 Items
50 Items
$299.99
Frank Thomas Signed White Sox 1990 Leaf Rookie Baseball Trading Card #300 - (PSA Encapsulated)
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$293.99
1993 CARLTON FISK Signed Topps Finest Card-HOF-WHITE SOX-RED SOX-Beckett
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$269.99
1993 Bowman Baseball Hobby Box Derek Jeter Rookie Year
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$276.99
Frank Thomas Autographed 1990 Leaf Rookie Card #300 Chicago White Sox PSA 9 Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 PSA/DNA Stock #220346
Ships Free
$269.99
Randy Johnson Gem Mint 10 PSA DNA Signed 1997 Fleer Metal Universe Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$277.99
Don Mattingly Signed 1992 Donruss #609 Yankees Baseball Card Auto PSA/DNA MT 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$271.99
David Ortiz PSA DNA Signed 1998 Donruss Signature Series Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$292.99
Sammy Sosa White Sox 1990 Fleer #548 Signed Card Auto Grade 10 BECKETT
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$256.99
1999 IVAN RODRIGUEZ Signed Skybox Card-HALL OF FAME-TEXAS RANGERS-PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$274.99
1998 JIM EDMONDS Signed Skybox Card-CARDINALS-ANAHEIM ANGELS-PSA 10 Auto
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$272.99
1995 Select Certified Derek Jeter Graded Card #122 Mirror Gold – SGC 8.5
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$277.99
Don Mattingly Signed 1991 Donruss #107 Yankees Baseball Card Auto PSA/DNA MT 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$283.99
Randy Johnson Psa/dna Signed 1990 Score Baseball Card #415 Autograph Hof
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$281.99
1994 Collector's Choice ROGER CLEMENS Signed Auto Card #348 Beckett BAS Slabbed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$293.99
Cal Ripken Jr Signed 1994 Upper Deck SP Card #126 PSA DNA HOF Baltimore Orioles
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$281.99
1994 Bowman ROGER CLEMENS Signed Auto Red Sox Card #475 Beckett BAS Slabbed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$254.99
BGS 9 Vladimir Guerrero 1995 Bowman's Best #B2 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$274.99
1993 WHITEY FORD Signed Upper Deck Bat Card-HOF-NEW YORK YANKEES-PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$290.99
Lou Whitaker Autographed 10 Grade 1991 Topps Tiffany
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$281.99
1992 Upper Deck ROGER CLEMENS Signed Auto Red Sox Card #641 Beckett BAS Slabbed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$281.99
1994 Collector's Choice ROGER CLEMENS Signed Auto Card #550 Beckett BAS Slabbed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$281.99
1996 Topps ROGER CLEMENS Signed Auto Red Sox Card #CC13 Beckett BAS Slabbed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$281.99
1994 Triple Play ROGER CLEMENS Signed Auto Red Sox Card #201 Beckett BAS Slabbed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$290.99
Lou Whitaker Autographed 10 Grade 1990 Topps Tiffany
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$277.99
Don Mattingly Signed 1996 Metal #90 Yankees Baseball Card Auto PSA/DNA MT 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$261.99
Sam Jones Autographed 1993 Action Packed #35 Trading Card PSA Slab 43808
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$254.99
Wade Boggs Harold Baines 1992 Fleer #707 Super Star Signed Card Beckett Auto HOF
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$293.99
Randy Johnson Signed 1998 Donruss Diamond Kings #9 Card Beckett Grade 10 Auto
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$272.99
Frank Thomas 1990 TOPPS ROOKIE (AFTER MARKET AUTO) #414 - PSA MINT 9/AUTO 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$281.99
1996 Pinnacle ROGER CLEMENS Signed Auto Red Sox Card #247 Beckett BAS Slabbed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$272.99
1996 Score Future Franchise #3 Derek Jeter PSA 9 Graded Baseball Card MLB INSERT
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$281.99
1994 Donruss MVPs ROGER CLEMENS Signed Auto Red Sox Card #15 Beckett BAS Slabbed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$281.99
1992 Upper Deck ROGER CLEMENS Signed Auto Red Sox Card #641 Beckett BAS Slabbed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$281.99
1995 Topps ROGER CLEMENS Signed Auto Red Sox Card #360 Beckett BAS Slabbed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$290.99
Lou Whitaker Autographed 10 Grade 1990 Bowman Tiffany
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$250.99
Nolan Ryan 1990 Topps Angels Baseball Card #3- Graded Gem Mint 10! (PSA)
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$256.99
1999 IVAN RODRIGUEZ Signed Upper Deck Card-HALL OF FAME-TEXAS RANGERS-PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$272.99
1999 Topps Hall Of Fame #hof6 Reggie Jackson Card New York Yankees Psa 10 Rare
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$271.99
MANNY RAMIREZ Signed 1992 Score ROOKIE Baseball Card #800 + PSA Auth Auto 709362
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$274.99
1993 WHITEY FORD Signed Upper Deck Bat Card-HOF-NEW YORK YANKEES-PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$256.99
1998 IVAN RODRIGUEZ Signed Fleer Card-HALL OF FAME-TEXAS RANGERS-PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$277.99
Don Mattingly Signed 1993 Score #23 Yankees Baseball Card Auto PSA/DNA MT 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$293.99
1998 MAGGLIO ORDONEZ Signed Topps ROOKIE Card-CHICAGO WHITE SOX-PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$254.99
1990 Topps #701 Bernie Williams Rc Yankees Psa 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$253.99
Roger Staubach Autographed 1994 Ted Williams Co POG Card - PSA/DNA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$256.99
1998 IVAN RODRIGUEZ Signed Skybox Card-HALL OF FAME-TEXAS RANGERS-PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$290.99
Roberto Alomar auto inscribed 1993 Topps Finest #88 PSA Encapsulated Blue Jays
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$281.99
1996 Score ROGER CLEMENS Signed Auto Red Sox Card #HG15 Beckett BAS Slabbed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$281.99
1990 Fleer ROGER CLEMENS Signed Auto Red Sox Card #271 Beckett BAS Slabbed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$291.99
1999 Fleer Mariano Rivera Signed/Autographed Card #136 Yankees PSA/DNA BA204423
Ships Free
Almost Gone