Free US Shipping on Orders Over $49.
Use code ST49SHIP
  1. baseball Memorabilia
  2. American League
  3. American League Trading Cards
Trading Cards
1 - 72 of 5732
...
5732 Items5732 Items
Kevin McGonigle 2026 Topps Now #7 4-Hit MLB Debut Rookie Card PGI 10
$50.99
Kevin McGonigle 2026 Topps Now #7 4-Hit MLB Debut Rookie Card PGI 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1985 Topps #181 Roger Clemens Rookie Card BGS BCCG 9 Near Mint+
$57.99
1985 Topps #181 Roger Clemens Rookie Card BGS BCCG 9 Near Mint+
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Kevin McGonigle 2024 Leaf #RA-89 Special Edition Rookie Card PGI 10
$50.99
Kevin McGonigle 2024 Leaf #RA-89 Special Edition Rookie Card PGI 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Colt Emerson 2023 1st Bowman #BD42 Seattle Mariners Rookie Card PGI 10
$50.99
Colt Emerson 2023 1st Bowman #BD42 Seattle Mariners Rookie Card PGI 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Jac Caglianone 2026 Topps Series 1 1991 Mega Box Crackle Foil Rookie Card RC
$69.99
Jac Caglianone 2026 Topps Series 1 1991 Mega Box Crackle Foil Rookie Card RC
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1963 TOPPS #348 VIC WERTZ Tigers PSA 6
$52.99
1963 TOPPS #348 VIC WERTZ Tigers PSA 6
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2025 Topps Heritage Brandon Drury Auto Los Angeles Angels #283 COA Card Signed
$57.99
2025 Topps Heritage Brandon Drury Auto Los Angeles Angels #283 COA Card Signed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2022 Topps Heritage High Number Kris Bubic Auto Kansas City Royals #589 COA Card
$57.99
2022 Topps Heritage High Number Kris Bubic Auto Kansas City Royals #589 COA Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2025 Topps Heritage Niko Kavadas Rookie Auto Los Angeles Angels #320 COA RC Card
$57.99
2025 Topps Heritage Niko Kavadas Rookie Auto Los Angeles Angels #320 COA RC Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1991 Upper Deck Final Edition Gerald Williams Rookie Auto Yankees #15F COA RC
$57.99
1991 Upper Deck Final Edition Gerald Williams Rookie Auto Yankees #15F COA RC
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2022 Topps Heritage High Number Griffin Canning Auto Los Angeles Angels #516 COA
$57.99
2022 Topps Heritage High Number Griffin Canning Auto Los Angeles Angels #516 COA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2024 Topps Heritage Carlos Estevez Auto Los Angeles Angels #498 COA Card Signed
$57.99
2024 Topps Heritage Carlos Estevez Auto Los Angeles Angels #498 COA Card Signed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2022 Topps Heritage High Number Trey Mancini Auto Houston Astros #545 COA Card
$57.99
2022 Topps Heritage High Number Trey Mancini Auto Houston Astros #545 COA Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2023 Topps Heritage High Number Carlos Estevez Auto Angels #702 SP COA Card
$57.99
2023 Topps Heritage High Number Carlos Estevez Auto Angels #702 SP COA Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2023 Topps Update Jonathan Loáisiga Auto New York Yankees #US227 COA Card Signed
$67.99
2023 Topps Update Jonathan Loáisiga Auto New York Yankees #US227 COA Card Signed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Roman Anthony 2025 Leaf HYPE! #177 Gold 25 Made Rookie Card PGI 10
$63.99
Roman Anthony 2025 Leaf HYPE! #177 Gold 25 Made Rookie Card PGI 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1988 Topps Alan Trammell Auto Detroit Tigers #429 COA Kirk Gibson Leaders Card
$67.99
1988 Topps Alan Trammell Auto Detroit Tigers #429 COA Kirk Gibson Leaders Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1991 Leaf Gold Rookies Mike Mussina Rookie Auto Baltimore Orioles #BC12 COA RC
$67.99
1991 Leaf Gold Rookies Mike Mussina Rookie Auto Baltimore Orioles #BC12 COA RC
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2022 Topps Heritage High Number Andrew Benintendi Auto New York Yankees #690 COA
$67.99
2022 Topps Heritage High Number Andrew Benintendi Auto New York Yankees #690 COA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2020 Topps Update Sam Haggerty Rookie Auto Seattle Mariners #U-152 COA RC Card
$67.99
2020 Topps Update Sam Haggerty Rookie Auto Seattle Mariners #U-152 COA RC Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1992 Topps Gold Winner Mike Mussina Auto Baltimore Orioles #242 COA HOF Card
$67.99
1992 Topps Gold Winner Mike Mussina Auto Baltimore Orioles #242 COA HOF Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2023 Topps Update Gold Sam Haggerty Auto 0939/2023 Seattle Mariners #US230 COA
$67.99
2023 Topps Update Gold Sam Haggerty Auto 0939/2023 Seattle Mariners #US230 COA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2024 Topps Heritage Everson Pereira Rookie Auto New York Yankees #348 COA RC
$67.99
2024 Topps Heritage Everson Pereira Rookie Auto New York Yankees #348 COA RC
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2024 Topps Heritage Michael Soroka Auto Chicago White Sox #69 SP COA Card Signed
$67.99
2024 Topps Heritage Michael Soroka Auto Chicago White Sox #69 SP COA Card Signed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2024 Topps Heritage Nick Loftin Rookie Auto Kansas City Royals #482 COA RC Card
$67.99
2024 Topps Heritage Nick Loftin Rookie Auto Kansas City Royals #482 COA RC Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2024 Topps Heritage Alex Lange Auto Detroit Tigers #213 COA Card Signed
$67.99
2024 Topps Heritage Alex Lange Auto Detroit Tigers #213 COA Card Signed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2024 Topps Holiday Logan Gilbert Auto Seattle Mariners #H156 COA Card Signed
$67.99
2024 Topps Holiday Logan Gilbert Auto Seattle Mariners #H156 COA Card Signed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2024 Topps Heritage High Number Logan Gilbert Auto Seattle Mariners #543 COA
$67.99
2024 Topps Heritage High Number Logan Gilbert Auto Seattle Mariners #543 COA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2022 Topps Update Royal Blue Jonathan Loaisiga Auto New York Yankees #US56 COA
$67.99
2022 Topps Update Royal Blue Jonathan Loaisiga Auto New York Yankees #US56 COA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1991 Score Mike Mussina Rookie Auto Baltimore Orioles #383 COA RC HOF Card
$67.99
1991 Score Mike Mussina Rookie Auto Baltimore Orioles #383 COA RC HOF Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Curt Schilling Rookie Card 1989 Procards #1655 BGS 9
$50.99
Curt Schilling Rookie Card 1989 Procards #1655 BGS 9
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Jackson Kowar Rookie Card 2021 Bowman Next Auto Orange (1/5) #BA59C PSA 9
$50.99
Jackson Kowar Rookie Card 2021 Bowman Next Auto Orange (1/5) #BA59C PSA 9
Ships Free
Almost Gone
George Brett Card 1981 Topps #700 BGS 8.5
$57.99
George Brett Card 1981 Topps #700 BGS 8.5
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Alex Rodriguez Rookie Card 1994 Action Packed #1 BGS 9.5
$57.99
Alex Rodriguez Rookie Card 1994 Action Packed #1 BGS 9.5
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Derek Jeter Rookie Card 1992 Classic Four Sport #231 BGS 9
$57.99
Derek Jeter Rookie Card 1992 Classic Four Sport #231 BGS 9
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Craig Biggio Rookie Card 1988 Score #103T BGS 9
$57.99
Craig Biggio Rookie Card 1988 Score #103T BGS 9
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Vladimir Guerrero Rookie Card 1995 SP Top Prospects #90 BGS 9
$57.99
Vladimir Guerrero Rookie Card 1995 SP Top Prospects #90 BGS 9
Ships Free
Almost Gone
David Ortiz Card 1998 Ultra #405 BGS BCCG 10
$57.99
David Ortiz Card 1998 Ultra #405 BGS BCCG 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Harmon Killebrew Card 1972 Topps #51 BGS BCCG 8 (holder issue)
$57.99
Harmon Killebrew Card 1972 Topps #51 BGS BCCG 8 (holder issue)
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2002 eTOPPS CLASSIC TOPPS #ETC18 NOLAN RYAN HOF POP 2 PSA 8
$54.99
2002 eTOPPS CLASSIC TOPPS #ETC18 NOLAN RYAN HOF POP 2 PSA 8
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Roger Clemens 2000 Topps 20Th Century Best Sequential (916/3316) #Cb12 BGS 9
$57.99
Roger Clemens 2000 Topps 20Th Century Best Sequential (916/3316) #Cb12 BGS 9
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Jeff Bagwell Rookie Card 1991 Upper Deck #755 BGS 9.5
$57.99
Jeff Bagwell Rookie Card 1991 Upper Deck #755 BGS 9.5
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Rod Carew Autographed 2018 Donruss Black & White Card #123 Card Minnesota Twins SKU #241218
$59.99
Rod Carew Autographed 2018 Donruss Black & White Card #123 Card Minnesota Twins SKU #241218
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Rod Carew Autographed 2018 Donruss Black & White Card #123 Card Minnesota Twins SKU #241219
$59.99
Rod Carew Autographed 2018 Donruss Black & White Card #123 Card Minnesota Twins SKU #241219
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Rod Carew Autographed 2011 Topps 60 Years of Topps Card #60YOT-21 Card Minnesota Twins SKU #241215
$59.99
Rod Carew Autographed 2011 Topps 60 Years of Topps Card #60YOT-21 Card Minnesota Twins SKU #241215
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Rod Carew Autographed 2011 Topps 60 Years of Topps Card #60YOT-21 Card Minnesota Twins SKU #241214
$59.99
Rod Carew Autographed 2011 Topps 60 Years of Topps Card #60YOT-21 Card Minnesota Twins SKU #241214
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1983 Topps Traded Ron Kittle Rookie Auto Chicago White Sox #55T RC Card Signed
$57.99
1983 Topps Traded Ron Kittle Rookie Auto Chicago White Sox #55T RC Card Signed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1989 Bowman George Bell Auto Toronto Blue Jays #256 COA Card Signed
$67.99
1989 Bowman George Bell Auto Toronto Blue Jays #256 COA Card Signed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Kazuma Okamoto 2026 Topps Now #25 1st MLB Home Run Rookie Card PGI 10
$50.99
Kazuma Okamoto 2026 Topps Now #25 1st MLB Home Run Rookie Card PGI 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Ben Rice 2025 Bowman #85 Rookie Card PGI 10
$50.99
Ben Rice 2025 Bowman #85 Rookie Card PGI 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Ben Rice 2025 Topps #337 Rookie Card PGI 10
$50.99
Ben Rice 2025 Topps #337 Rookie Card PGI 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Ben Rice 2025 Stadium Club #196 Rookie Card PGI 10
$50.99
Ben Rice 2025 Stadium Club #196 Rookie Card PGI 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1966 Topps #365 Roger Maris New York Yankees Baseball Card Low Grade READ
$67.99
1966 Topps #365 Roger Maris New York Yankees Baseball Card Low Grade READ
Ships Free
Almost Gone
2021 Topps Rip Mini Autographs George Springer Gold #RIPAUGS On Card Auto /5
$64.99
2021 Topps Rip Mini Autographs George Springer Gold #RIPAUGS On Card Auto /5
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Mike Trout 2025 Topps 582 Montgomery #200 Foil SP Rare Trading Card PGI 10
$63.99
Mike Trout 2025 Topps 582 Montgomery #200 Foil SP Rare Trading Card PGI 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Bobby Witt Jr. 2025 Topps 582 Montgomery #100 Foil SP Rare Trading Card PGI 10
$63.99
Bobby Witt Jr. 2025 Topps 582 Montgomery #100 Foil SP Rare Trading Card PGI 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Pete Alonso 2025 Topps 582 Montgomery #550 Foil SP Rare Trading Card PGI 10
$63.99
Pete Alonso 2025 Topps 582 Montgomery #550 Foil SP Rare Trading Card PGI 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Vladimir Guerrero 2025 Topps 582 Montgomery #163 Foil SP Rare Trading Card PGI
$63.99
Vladimir Guerrero 2025 Topps 582 Montgomery #163 Foil SP Rare Trading Card PGI
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Ben Rice 2025 Topps Chrome #USC138 Rookie Card PGI 10
$63.99
Ben Rice 2025 Topps Chrome #USC138 Rookie Card PGI 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Bronx Bombers 2025 Topps 582 Montgomery #184 Foil SP Rare Trading Card PGI 10
$63.99
Bronx Bombers 2025 Topps 582 Montgomery #184 Foil SP Rare Trading Card PGI 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1990 Topps #380 Dave Winfield Yankees Hof Psa 10
$74.99
1990 Topps #380 Dave Winfield Yankees Hof Psa 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Julio Rodriguez Rookie 2022 Topps Chrome Update Purple Refractors #USC165 BGS 9
$50.99
Julio Rodriguez Rookie 2022 Topps Chrome Update Purple Refractors #USC165 BGS 9
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Luke Easter Card 1952 Topps Black Back #24 PSA 2 MK
$50.99
Luke Easter Card 1952 Topps Black Back #24 PSA 2 MK
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Ken Griffey Jr. Rookie Card 1989 Score Traded #100T BGS 9
$72.99
Ken Griffey Jr. Rookie Card 1989 Score Traded #100T BGS 9
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Carlton Fisk Rookie Card 1972 Topps #79 BGS BCCG 7
$72.99
Carlton Fisk Rookie Card 1972 Topps #79 BGS BCCG 7
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Alex Rodriguez Rookie Card 1994 SP #15 BGS 8
$72.99
Alex Rodriguez Rookie Card 1994 SP #15 BGS 8
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1972 Topps #326 Pat Kelly Rc White Sox Psa 9
$74.99
1972 Topps #326 Pat Kelly Rc White Sox Psa 9
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Aaron Judge Rookie Card 2017 Topps Update #US1 PSA 8
$72.99
Aaron Judge Rookie Card 2017 Topps Update #US1 PSA 8
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Frank Thomas Rookie Card 1990 Leaf #300 BGS 9
$72.99
Frank Thomas Rookie Card 1990 Leaf #300 BGS 9
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Adrian Beltre/Brooks Robinson Card 2009 Topps Heritage #TN-3 PSA 10
$57.99
Adrian Beltre/Brooks Robinson Card 2009 Topps Heritage #TN-3 PSA 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1957 Topps Brooks Robinson Highland Mint Card
$56.99
1957 Topps Brooks Robinson Highland Mint Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1972 Topps #566 Reggie Smith Boston Red Sox In Action Baseball Card Nm+
$54.99
1972 Topps #566 Reggie Smith Boston Red Sox In Action Baseball Card Nm+
Ships Free
Almost Gone
...