Skip to Main Content
Skip to Filters
Skip to Filters
Skip to Footer
Track my Order
Help
My Account
NFL
MLB
NBA
More
NHL
NCAA
SOCCER
WWE
Display Cases
GAME USED
TRADING CARDS
NEW ARRIVALS
Outlet
NHL
NCAA
SOCCER
More
WWE
Display Cases
GAME USED
TRADING CARDS
NEW ARRIVALS
Outlet
WWE
More Sports
Display Cases
GAME USED
TRADING CARDS
NEW ARRIVALS
Players
Outlet
Free US Shipping on Orders Over $49.
Use code
ST49SHIP
Terms
baseball Memorabilia
American League
American League Trading Cards
American League
Filter & Sort
Cancel
Your Selections
American League
Trading Cards
$200 to $250
Filter By
Signed
Sub Department
Autographed Cards
Autographed Rookie Cards
Rookie Cards
Singles
Vintage Cards
Decade
1930-1939
1940-1949
1950-1959
1960-1969
1970-1979
1980-1989
1990-1999
2000-2009
2010-2019
2020-2029
Authenticator
Beckett
CGC
James Spence Authentication
Panini
PSA
Schwartz Sports
Upper Deck
Athletes
Derek Jeter
Aaron Judge
Al Hrabosky
Al Kaline
Alan Trammell
Albert Pujols
Alex Rodriguez
Andy Pettitte
Aroldis Chapman
Babe Ruth
Trading Cards
Filters
1 - 72 of 1012
Top Sellers
LowestPrice
HighestPrice
TopSellers
NewestArrivals
72 Items
24
48
72
1
2
3
4
...
15
1
2
3
15
next page
American League
Trading Cards
$200 to $250
1012 Items
1012 Items
$231.99
Derek Jeter Card 2013 Topps Emerald #373 PSA 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$210.99
2022 Finest Autographs Gold Refractor FAJL Josh Lowe Rookie Auto/50 BGS 9.5
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$213.99
2024 Topps Triple Threads Mike Trout Jumbo Relic 3 MVP /27 Angels BGS HOF
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$228.99
C.C. SABATHIA YANKEES TOPPS FIVE STAR GOLD AUTOGRAPH /10 Bgs 9 POP 1
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$246.99
Harold Baines Signed 1981 Topps #347 PSA 10 Auto RC Rookie Chicago White Sox
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$228.99
2005 Topps Update All-Star Stitches David Ortiz #ASR-DO Player Worn BGS 9.5 Pop
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$228.99
Cal Ripken Junior 2006 topps triple threads #88 sepia BGS 9 /150 HOF Caliber
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$228.99
2024 Topps x Berman Boomer's Baseball - Ken Griffey Jr. Gold 52/149 BGS 9
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$228.99
2024 Bowman's Best "SHOTS BY THE KID" TK-15 KEN GRIFFEY JR BGS 9.5
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$235.99
1956 Topps #118 Nellie Fox Chicago White Sox Baseball Card Sgc 6 Ex/mt
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$235.99
1961 Topps #425 Yogi Berra New York Yankees Baseball Card Sgc 4.5 Vg/ex+
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$230.99
SHOHEI OHTANI PHENOM K's 11 SET ANGELS RECORD TOPPS NOW JAPANESE KANJI CARD 210J
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$207.99
1958 Topps #485 Ted Williams All Star Boston Red Sox Nice Great Color HOF
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$231.99
Aaron Judge Rookie Card 2017 Topps High Tek Blackout #AJ PSA 9
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$231.99
Derek Jeter Rookie Card 1993 SP Foil #279 BGS 6.5
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$228.99
2024 Topps Chrome Sapphire #USA-JAL Jack Leiter Rookie RC Autograph /199
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$237.99
2017 ROD CAREW Signed Allen & Ginter Topps Card-HOF-ANGELS-TWINS-PSA 10 Auto
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$237.99
2019 ROD CAREW Signed Allen & Ginter Topps Card-HOF-ANGELS-TWINS-PSA 10 Auto
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$237.99
2024 ROD CAREW Signed Allen & Ginter Topps Card-HOF-ANGELS-TWINS-PSA 10 Auto
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$218.99
2020 WADE BOGGS Signed Topps Baseball Card-BOSTON RED SOX-PSA 10 Auto
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$237.99
2020 ROD CAREW Signed Allen & Ginter Topps Card-HOF-ANGELS-TWINS-PSA 10 Auto
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$246.99
2021 FRANK THOMAS Signed Topps Allen & Ginter Card-HOF-WHITE SOX-PSA 10 Auto
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$246.99
2016 EDGAR MARTINEZ Signed Topps Allen & Ginter-HOF-SEATTLE MARINERS-PSA 10 Auto
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$246.99
2013 FRANK THOMAS Signed Topps Allen & Ginter Card-HOF-WHITE SOX-PSA 10 Auto
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$241.99
2018 Leaf Pop Century Silver Prismatic Jon Heder & Reggie Jackson Autograph 3/4
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$246.99
2022 EDGAR MARTINEZ Signed Topps Allen & Ginter-HOF-SEATTLE MARINERS-PSA 10 Auto
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$231.99
Babe Ruth Card 1962 Topps Green Tint #137A BGS BVG 8
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$231.99
Dave Stieb signed 1980 Topps #77 RC Rookie Card autograph BAS BGS 10 Auto
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$207.99
2011 Panini Playoff Prime Cuts Yogi Berra Signed On Card Auto Yankees HOF
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$208.99
Hideo Nomo 1998 Flair Showcase Row 0 /500 Baseball Card #59 Beckett Bgs 9 Mint
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$226.99
Jerry Coleman Beckett BAS Signed 1952 Topps Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$212.99
2009 Topps WBC Stars Venezuela Miguel Cabrera #BCS14 On Card Auto PSA Authentic
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$218.99
Reggie Jackson PSA DNA Vintage Signed 1979 Topps Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$244.99
1963 Topps #120 Roger Maris PSA 5 Graded Baseball Card MLB New York Yankees
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$239.99
1997 Topps Stadium Club Bernie Williams #57 Signed Auto Card Beckett 10 Auth
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$207.99
1997 Donruss Bernie Williams #169 Signed Auto Card Beckett Authentic
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$207.99
1997 Fleer Bernie Williams #181 Signed Auto Card Beckett Auth Yankees
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$207.99
1996 Upper Deck Jorge Posada #159 Signed Auto Card Beckett 10 Authentic Yankees
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$207.99
1983 Donruss Wade Boggs #586 Signed Auto Card Beckett Authentic Red Sox
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$239.99
1981 Topps Mark Fidrych #150 Signed Auto Card Beckett Authentic Tigers
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$207.99
1997 Donruss Andy Pettite #82 Signed Auto Card Beckett 10 Authentic Yankees
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$207.99
1997 Fleer Andy Pettite #175 Signed Auto Card Beckett Authentic Yankees
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$249.99
Frank Thomas Signed White Sox 1990 Topps Rookie Baseball Card #414 w/HOF 2014 - (PSA Encapsulated)
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$245.99
Jim Rice SGC Coa Signed 1975 Topps Rookie Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$228.99
2024 Topps Triple Threads #RAR-EC Evan Carter Blue Rookie Patch Autograph /10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$231.99
Al Kaline Gem Mint 10 Beckett BAS Signed 1964 Topps Giants Autographed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$239.99
1982 CARLTON FISK Signed Topps Card-HOF-WHITE SOX-RED SOX-PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$237.99
1988 CARLTON FISK Signed Starting Lineup Card-HOF-WHITE SOX-RED SOX-Beckett
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$214.99
Frank Thomas Autographed 1990 Leaf Rookie Card #300 Chicago White Sox PSA 9 Auto Grade Mint 9 PSA/DNA Stock #262019
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$231.99
Eddie Murray Signed 1989 Topps #87T Baseball Card Orioles Auto PSA/DNA MINT 9
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$241.99
1963 Topps #228 Tony Oliva RC PSA 3.5 *3823
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$231.99
Al Kaline Gem Mint 10 Beckett BAS Signed 1964 Topps Giants Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$232.99
1961 Topps #307 Mickey Mantle Slams 2 Homers World Series Card Sgc 4 Vg/ex
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$232.99
1961 Topps #472 Yogi Berra New York Yankees Mvp Baseball Card Sgc 5 Ex
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$203.99
2023 Topps #8 Mike Trout Throwback Thursday Pink '58 Topps #2/5 PSA 8 (NM-MT)
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$229.99
Frank Thomas Autographed 1990 Topps Rookie Card #414 Chicago White Sox PSA 9 Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 PSA/DNA Stock #250509
Ships Free
$229.99
2007 Upper Deck Cal Ripken Jr. Signed Baseball Card Auto PSA DNA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$203.99
1964 Topps Baseball #146 Tommy John & Bob Chance Rookie PSA 7 (NM)
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$229.99
2007 Upper Deck Cal Ripken Jr. Signed Baseball Card Auto PSA DNA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$229.99
Tony Oilva HOF Signed/Auto 1964 TOPPS Giants Card #44 Twins PSA/DNA 205209
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$201.99
Mickey Mantle Rival All Stars 1960 Topps Baseball Card #160 Psa 4 Vg-ex Yankees
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$204.99
Derek Jeter 1993 Upper Deck Sp Rookie Card #279 (PSA EX 5)
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$247.99
1991 Classic Nolan Ryan Signed Baseball Card Auto PSA DNA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$229.99
2007 Upper Deck Cal Ripken Jr. Signed Baseball Card Auto PSA DNA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$246.99
Aaron Judge Powers Ny Yankees Record Day 3 Hr Game Topps Now Gold Foil Card #18
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$246.99
Amed Rosario Game Used Base Relic Auto Topps Now Card 692a Little League Classic
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$204.99
1975 Topps (reg size) 6 Card Uncut Sheet Section with Thurman Munson, etc.
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$229.99
2007 Upper Deck Cal Ripken Jr. Signed Baseball Card Auto PSA DNA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$200.99
Max Fried Signed 2012 Leaf Valiant #VA-MF1 Baseball Yankees Auto 95/99 PSA/DNA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$217.99
Roman Anthony 2025 Topps Now Baseball Rookie Card #607 Graded PSA 10 Cert #129785289
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$235.99
Psa 8 1960 Nu-card Baseball #46 Tigers Beat Out Senators
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$244.99
Mariano Rivera 2024 Leaf Collective Pro Set Autographed Blue Shimmer Card #PSA-MR2 2/10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1
2
3
4
...
15
1
2
3
15
next page