Skip to Main Content
Skip to Filters
Skip to Filters
Skip to Footer
Track my Order
Help
My Account
NFL
MLB
NBA
More
NHL
NCAA
SOCCER
WWE
Display Cases
GAME USED
TRADING CARDS
NEW ARRIVALS
Outlet
NHL
NCAA
SOCCER
More
WWE
Display Cases
GAME USED
TRADING CARDS
NEW ARRIVALS
Outlet
WWE
More Sports
Display Cases
GAME USED
TRADING CARDS
NEW ARRIVALS
Players
Outlet
Free US Shipping on Orders Over $49.
Use code
ST49SHIP
Terms
baseball Memorabilia
Cleveland Guardians
Cleveland Guardians Trading Cards
Cleveland Guardians
Filter & Sort
Cancel
Your Selections
Cleveland Guardians
Trading Cards
1990-1999
Filter By
Signed
Sub Department
Autographed Cards
Autographed Rookie Cards
Rookie Cards
Singles
Authenticator
Beckett
PSA
Schwartz Sports
Upper Deck
Athletes
Bartolo Colon
Carlos Martinez
Dwight Gooden
Harold Baines
Herb Score
Jason Giambi
Jim Thome
Joe Carter
John Farrell
Keith Hernandez
Price Range / Sale
Less than $25
$25 to $50
$50 to $75
$75 to $100
$100 to $150
Over $300
Trading Cards
Filters
1 - 72 of 188
Top Sellers
LowestPrice
HighestPrice
TopSellers
NewestArrivals
72 Items
24
48
72
1
2
3
1
2
3
next page
Cleveland Guardians
Trading Cards
1990-1999
188 Items
188 Items
$38.99
1996 Topps #45 Albert Belle Indians Pop 5 Psa 9
Almost Gone
$75.99
Carlos Martinez Signed 1993 Upper Deck Indians Trading Card Beckett
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$97.99
Keith Hernandez Cleveland Indians 1990 Upper Deck Signed Card #777
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$92.99
1994 Topps #480 Albert Belle Indians Psa 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$28.99
Sandy Alomar signed 1990 Donruss Diamond Kings On Card Auto #13- COA - Cleveland
Almost Gone
$23.99
Brad Arnsberg autographed Baseball Card (Oklahoma City 89ers) 1990 ProCards Rookie #669
Almost Gone
$21.99
Heath Murray autographed baseball card (Minor League All Star) 1996 Best #35
Almost Gone
$21.99
Jason Giambi Rookie Card 1991 Topps Traded #45T PSA 9
Almost Gone
$24.99
Glenallen Hill autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1992 Upper Deck #558
Almost Gone
$24.99
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians Signed 1992 Score Card #409
Almost Gone
$23.99
Herb Score autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1994 Upper Deck BAT #56 ballpoint
Almost Gone
$24.99
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians Signed 1993 Upper Deck Card #544
Almost Gone
$24.99
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians Signed 1991 Topps Traded Card #858
Almost Gone
$24.99
Tom Candiotti Cleveland Indians Signed 1991 Topps Card #624
Almost Gone
$24.99
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians Signed 1992 Upper Deck Final Card #656
Almost Gone
$21.99
Jaret Wright autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1994 Upper Deck Prospect Rookie #201
Almost Gone
$21.99
Chad Ogea autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1995 Topps Star Track #47
Almost Gone
$21.99
Mark Lewis autographed baseball card (Cleveland Indians) 1991 Donruss The Rookies #42
Almost Gone
$24.99
Greg Swindell autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1990 Bowman #325
Almost Gone
$24.99
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians Signed 1993 Topps Card #496
Almost Gone
$24.99
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians Signed 1993 Fleer Ultra Card #541
Almost Gone
$24.99
Joey Cora Cleveland Indians Signed 1999 Fleer Tradition Card #411
Almost Gone
$24.99
1991 ProCards Canton-Akron Indians Cleveland Minor League Baseball Complete set
Almost Gone
$23.99
John Farrell Cleveland Indians Autographed 1991 Topps #664 Signed Baseball Card
Almost Gone
$24.99
Jerry Browne autographed baseball card (Cleveland Indians) 1990 Score #52
Almost Gone
$21.99
David Bell autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1994 Upper Deck #16
Almost Gone
$23.99
Alan Embree autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1993 Upper Deck Star Rookie #12
Almost Gone
$27.99
Carlos Baerga Cleveland Indians Signed 1990 Score Traded Card #74t
Almost Gone
$24.99
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians Signed 1992 Fleer Card #113
Almost Gone
$21.99
David Segui autographed Baseball Card (Rochester Red Wings) 1991 Impel Pre Rookie #466
Almost Gone
$23.99
Rick Manning autographed Baseball Card (Fort Myers Sun Sox) 1990 Elite #73
Almost Gone
$24.99
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians Signed 1993 Fleer Card #594
Almost Gone
$24.99
Reggie Jefferson autographed baseball card (Cleveland Indians) 1991 Donruss The Rookies #55
Almost Gone
$24.99
Mark Lewis autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1992 Fleer Ultra #51
Almost Gone
$21.99
Beau Allred autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1991 Upper Deck #784
Almost Gone
$24.99
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians Signed 1991 Upper Deck Final Card #73f
Almost Gone
$21.99
Dave Mlicki signed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1993 Upper Deck Star Rookie #17
Almost Gone
$24.99
Carlos Baerga Cleveland Indians Signed 1990 Topps Traded Card #6t
Almost Gone
$24.99
Shawn Hillegas autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1992 Topps Stadium Club #76
Almost Gone
$25.99
Jim Thome 1991 Upper Deck Final Edition Cleveland Rookie Card (RC) #17F (Diamond Skills/HOF/5X All-Star)
Almost Gone
$24.99
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians Signed 1994 Fleer Card #106
Almost Gone
$21.99
Dave Mlicki autographed baseball card (Canton Akron Indians) 1992 Classic Best #39
Almost Gone
$24.99
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians Signed 1993 Donruss Card #303
Almost Gone
$24.99
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians Signed 1992 Topps Card #93
Almost Gone
$24.99
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians Signed 1994 Score Card #391
Almost Gone
$24.99
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians Signed 1994 Donruss Card #653
Almost Gone
$23.99
Charles Nagy Cleveland Indians 1993 Score Pinnacle #65 Autographed Signed Card
Almost Gone
$24.99
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians Signed 1991 Donruss Rookies Card #55
Almost Gone
$24.99
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians Signed 1993 Score Card #433
Almost Gone
$21.99
Joel Skinner autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1990 Fleer #501
Almost Gone
$24.99
Mitch Webster signed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1990 Topps Traded #127T
Almost Gone
$24.99
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians Signed 1992 Donruss Card #12
Almost Gone
$24.99
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians Signed 1994 Topps Card #121
Almost Gone
$24.99
Reggie Jefferson Cleveland Indians Signed 1992 Fleer Ultra Card #50
Almost Gone
$101.99
1997 Topps #318 Manny Ramirez Indians Psa 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$19.99
Carlos Baerga Cleveland Indians Signed 1991 Score Card #74
Almost Gone
$19.99
Carlos Baerga Cleveland Indians Signed 1992 Upper Deck Card #231
Almost Gone
$19.99
Dave Mlicki Cleveland Indians Signed 1993 Upper Deck Card #17
Almost Gone
$19.99
Butch Benton St. Pete Pelicans Senior League Signed 1990 Pacific Card #24
Almost Gone
$19.99
1993 Fleer ProCards Burlington Indians Complete Baseball Team set Minor
Almost Gone
$19.99
Carlos Baerga Cleveland Indians Signed 1992 Topps Card #33
Almost Gone
$28.99
Jim Thome 1991 Upper Deck Final Edition Cleveland Rookie Card (RC) #17F- Lot of 3 (Diamond Skills/HOF/5X All-Star)
Almost Gone
$26.99
Carlos Baerga autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1990 Topps Traded #6T
Almost Gone
$26.99
Carlos Baerga autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1995 Topps Embossed #95
Almost Gone
$32.99
Sandy Alomar Jr Cleveland Indians Signed 1995 Topps Stadium Card #217
Almost Gone
$28.99
Julio Franco autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1996 Fleer #U31
Almost Gone
$32.99
Jack Armstrong Cleveland Indians Signed 1992 Topps Traded Card #6t
Almost Gone
$30.99
Vern Ruhle autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1990 Swell Legends #76 ballpoint
Almost Gone
$32.99
Sandy Alomar Jr Cleveland Indians Signed 1993 Fleer Card #98
Almost Gone
$32.99
Carlos Baerga Cleveland Indians Signed 1990 Fleer Update Card #u-90
Almost Gone
$29.99
Joe Hauser (d.1997) Autographed 1992 Conlon Sporting News Card #548 Signed
Almost Gone
$26.99
Carlos Baerga autographed Baseball Card (Cleveland Indians) 1993 Topps Magazine #TM97
Almost Gone
1
2
3
1
2
3
next page
