Skip to Main Content
Skip to Filters
Skip to Filters
Skip to Footer
Track my Order
Help
My Account
NFL
MLB
NBA
More
NHL
NCAA
SOCCER
WWE
Display Cases
GAME USED
TRADING CARDS
NEW ARRIVALS
Outlet
NHL
NCAA
SOCCER
More
WWE
Display Cases
GAME USED
TRADING CARDS
NEW ARRIVALS
Outlet
WWE
More Sports
Display Cases
GAME USED
TRADING CARDS
NEW ARRIVALS
Players
Outlet
Free US Shipping on Orders Over $49.
Use code
ST49SHIP
Terms
baseball Memorabilia
Cleveland Guardians
Cleveland Guardians Trading Cards
Cleveland Guardians
Filter & Sort
Cancel
Your Selections
Cleveland Guardians
Trading Cards
Over $300
Filter By
Signed
Sub Department
Autographed Cards
Autographed Rookie Cards
Rookie Cards
Singles
Vintage Cards
Trading Card Departments
Singles
Decade
1930-1939
1940-1949
1950-1959
1960-1969
1970-1979
1980-1989
1990-1999
2000-2009
2010-2019
2020-2029
Authenticator
Beckett
PSA
Upper Deck
Grade
10
Trading Card Features
1-of-1
Graded
Relic
Rookie Card
Slabbed
Athletes
Andrew Miller
Austin Jackson
Bob Feller
Corey Kluber
Dennis Eckersley
Francisco Lindor
Harold Baines
Herb Score
Hoyt Wilhelm
Jack Morris
Trading Cards
Filters
1 - 72 of 174
Top Sellers
LowestPrice
HighestPrice
TopSellers
NewestArrivals
72 Items
24
48
72
1
2
3
1
2
3
next page
Cleveland Guardians
Trading Cards
Over $300
174 Items
174 Items
$446.99
1956 Topps #200 Bob Feller PSA 5
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$312.99
1977 DENNIS ECKERSLEY Signed Topps Card-HOF-CLEVELAND INDIANS-PSA 10 Auto
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$1,414.99
1986 Joe Carter Topps Tiffany Baseball Card #377 Cleveland Indians PSA Gem Mt 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$941.99
1956 Topps #140 Herb Score RC AUTO PSA 4 PSA/DNA AUTO 8 POP 3 ONLY 5 Higher
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$461.99
Harry Simpson Autographed 1952 Topps Card #193 Cleveland Indians Beckett BAS #18969313
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$384.99
Bob Feller Gem Mint 10 Beckett BAS Signed 1960 Nu-Card Hi-Lites Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$599.99
1952 Topps #88 Bob Feller Cleveland Indians Baseball Card Sgc 3 Vg Nice
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$474.99
Jim Thome Signed Indians 1991 UD #17F Rookie Card PSA GEM MT 10 AUTO AUTH
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$384.99
Manny Ramirez Autographed 1992 Topps Rookie Card #156 Cleveland Indians Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 Beckett BAS Stock #239948
Ships Free
$384.99
Manny Ramirez Autographed 1992 Stadium Club SE Skydome Rookie Card #146 Cleveland Indians Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 Beckett BAS Stock #239946
Ships Free
$458.99
Bob Feller PSA DNA Vintage Signed 1955 Bowman Autographed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$538.99
Bob Feller PSA DNA Vintage Signed 1950 Bowman Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$392.99
Bob Feller Mint 9 PSA DNA Signed 1954 Bowman Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$458.99
Bob Feller PSA DNA Vintage Signed 1955 Bowman Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$1,079.99
Bob Feller PSA DNA Vintage Signed 1949 Bowman Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$616.99
Manny Ramirez Autographed 1992 Bowman Foil Rookie Card #676 Cleveland Indians PSA 8 Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 PSA/DNA Stock #239736
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$392.99
Sam Rice PSA DNA Signed 1960 Fleer Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$323.99
1956 Topps #187 Early Wynn Cleveland Indians Baseball Card Sgc 6 Ex/mt
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$442.99
1957 EARLY WYNN Signed Topps Baseball Card-HOF-CLEVELAND INDIANS-PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$523.99
Tommy John Indians Autographed 1964 Topps Rookie #146 PSA/DNA Auto 193413
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$326.99
1958 Topps #424 Larry Doby PSA 6 Graded Baseball Card MLB Cleveland Indians
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$616.99
Manny Ramirez Autographed 1992 Bowman Rookie Card #532 Cleveland Indians PSA 9 Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 PSA/DNA Stock #239735
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$540.99
Valmy Thomas Beckett BAS Signed 1958 Topps Rookie Key Card Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$597.99
2016 Topps Now #OS-25 Tyler Naquin Cleveland Indians All-Star Rookie Team BGS 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$490.99
1923 1924 Exhibits George Burns PSA 3 Graded Baseball Card Exhibit Cleveland
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$442.99
1960 EARLY WYNN Signed Topps Baseball Card-HOF-CLEVELAND INDIANS-PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$538.99
Manny Ramirez Autographed 1992 Bowman Gold Foil Rookie Card #676 Cleveland Indians Beckett BAS #17856426
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$544.99
1951 Bowman #151 Larry Doby PSA 4 Graded Baseball Card Cleveland Indians MLB
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$538.99
Manny Ramirez Autographed 1992 Bowman Gold Foil Rookie Card #676 Cleveland Indians Beckett BAS #17856427
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$647.99
Rocky Colavito Gem Mint 10 PSA DNA Signed 1957 Topps Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$617.99
Bob Feller Signed 1951 Bowman #30 Autograph Baseball Card Autograph PSA/DNA 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$388.99
1962 EARLY WYNN Signed Topps Baseball Card-HOF-CLEVELAND INDIANS-PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$353.99
Manny Ramirez Autographed 1992 Topps Rookie Card #156 Cleveland Indians Beckett BAS #17856469
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$672.99
1979 Topps #122 Mike Paxton - Indians - PSA 10 - 18951415 - Baseball Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$672.99
1979 Topps #438 Horace Speed - Indians - PSA 10 - 18951413 - Baseball Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$452.99
Chico Salmon Beckett BAS Signed 1965 Topps Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$544.99
1965 Topps #145 Luis Tiant ROOKIE RC PSA 8 (OC) Graded Baseball Card MLB Indians
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$336.99
Larry Doby PSA DNA Signed 1959 Topps Autographed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$465.99
2021 TOPPS NOW 291 TRISTON MCKENZIE INDIANS ROOKIE 8 Ks RED Parallel/10 BGS 9.5
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$364.99
Jim Thome Signed Indians 1991 Upper Deck Rookie Card #17F MINT 9 AUTO AUTH PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$461.99
Bob Feller PSA DNA Vintage Signed 1953 Topps Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$333.99
1952 Topps #88 Bob Feller Cleveland Indians Baseball Card Vg/Ex o/c twoc
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$353.99
Manny Ramirez Autographed 1992 Score Rookie Card #800 Cleveland Indians Beckett BAS Stock #239950
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$588.99
1954 Topps #70 Larry Doby PSA 5 Graded Baseball Card MLB Cleveland Indians
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$616.99
Manny Ramirez Autographed 1992 Bowman Foil Rookie Card #676 Cleveland Indians Auto Grade Gem Mint 10 PSA/DNA Stock #239737
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$672.99
1979 Topps #705 Indians Prospects - PSA 10 - 17655001 - Baseball Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$443.99
Rocky Colavito PSA DNA Vintage Signed 1957 Topps Rookie Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$388.99
Harold Baines Signed 2019 Topps Now #546 HOF Card Beckett Grade 10 Auto RARE
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$328.99
Jim Thome Signed Indians 1991 Upper Deck Rookie Card PSA Authentic AUTO
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$468.99
Terry Francona Signed Last Game Topps Now #928 Sealed On-card Auto 99 Or Lower
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$590.99
Bob Chakales (d.2010) Cleveland Autographed 1952 Topps #120 Signed Vintage Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$308.99
Bob Feller SIGNED 2005 Upper Deck Card Indians (DEC) PSA/DNA AUTOGRAPHED
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$693.99
Rare 1958 HOYT WILHELM Signed Topps Card-HALL OF FAME-CLEVELAND INDIANS-PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$339.99
1958 Topps #47 Roger Maris Cleveland Indians Rookie Baseball Card (writing)
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$396.99
Sam Rice PSA DNA Signed 1960 Fleer Autographed
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$576.99
1954 BOB LEMON Signed Bowman Card-Playing Days Signature-HOF-INDIANS-PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$325.99
Jack Morris 1982 Topps Baseball Card #450 Psa 10 Gem Mint Graded Tigerrs Hof
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$472.99
1954 Cleveland Indians 2017 Historic Autographs Line-Ups Cut Auto Card 8/10 -BAS
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$452.99
Harry Simpson Signed Autographed Heilbroner Card Stars Indian Color Barrier BAS
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$353.99
Manny Ramirez Autographed 1992 Stadium Club SE Skydome Rookie Card #146 Cleveland Indians Beckett BAS #17856465
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$547.99
Jim Thome Siged Indians 1991 Upper Deck Rookie Card PSA Graded MINT 9 AUTO 10
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$574.99
Rare 1955 BOB LEMON Signed Bowman Card-HOF-CLEVELAND INDIANS-PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$464.99
Francisco Lindor Signed 2015 Topps Update Rookie Trading Card Indians PSA/DNA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$550.99
1967 Topps #580 Rocky Colavito Cleveland Indians Baseball Card Psa 4.5 Vg/ex+
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$420.99
Bob Feller PSA DNA Signed 1953 Topps Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$430.99
George Banks PSA DNA Vintage Signed 1965 Topps Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$340.99
Joe Adcock Signed 1967 Topps Card High #563 Auto with B&E Hologram
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$363.99
1963 Fleer #13 Jerry Kindall PSA 9 Graded Baseball Card MLB Cleveland Indians
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$430.99
Bob Feller PSA DNA Signed 1955 Bowman Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$455.99
Chico Salmon Beckett BAS Signed 1965 Topps Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$482.99
Rare 1958 BOB LEMON Signed Topps Card-HALL OF FAME-CLEVELAND INDIANS-PSA
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$486.99
Bob Feller PSA DNA Vintage Signed 1955 Bowman Autograph
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1
2
3
1
2
3
next page
