Up to 25% Off Savings
Up to 25% Off Savings. Each offer has a limited duration that expires at the specified time. Some promotions may require that you enter a code. By making a purchase featuring a discount or promotion, including where a code may be required, you are agreeing to these terms and exclusions. Generally, eligibility will be as reflected in the price shown on the product page. However, discounts and promotions for certain products may only appear once an item is added to the cart and the code is entered. Prices and fees, including any applicable discount(s), will be as reflected in the cart. Only the as-discounted retail price (excluding applicable shipping, taxes, and handling fees) counts toward any minimum spend required for eligibility. If a rewards program applies, the rewards may only apply to the as-discounted retail price. Discounts and promotions do not apply to gift cards. Gift card purchases do not count toward any minimum spend required for eligibility. Exclusions may apply, including: all auctions and product drops; product that is already on sale, of limited quantity, for recent championship or other special events; trading cards and certain memorabilia; select jerseys, on-field headwear, die cast and certain collectibles; and certain premium brand product. Additional terms and other exclusions may apply in our sole discretion. Items listed as FINAL SALE on the product page are final sale and cannot be returned. Free shipping promotions are valid in Continental U.S., US Territories, and AFO/FPO only, such promotions exclude heavy, large, and/or bulky items, and free shipping does not apply to the extent your cart at checkout contains any excluded item(s). Shipping method and timing may vary. Expected delivery times are based on in-stock items and the specified zip code, if applicable. Delivery estimates are not guaranteed.
  1. baseball Memorabilia
  2. New York Mets
  3. New York Mets Baseballs
  4. Gary Carter Memorabilia
1 - 61 of 61
Baseballs
61 Items
  • 1
  • 1 of 1
Almost Gone!
$191.99
$212.99
Sale
Gary Carter PSA DNA Autograph National League Signed Baseball
Almost Gone!
$298.99
$331.99
Sale
Gary Carter Autographed Official Major League Baseball PSA/DNA Expos Mets
Almost Gone!
$83.99
$92.99
Sale
Gary Carter Signed Pepsi Ad Autograph 1986 NY Mets Baseball HOF WSC MLB PSA/DNA
Almost Gone!
$497.99
$552.99
Sale
Gary Carter Signed Official NL Baseball NY Mets 86 WS Champs Bold Auto PSA HOF
Almost Gone!
$399.99
$443.99
Sale
1985 - 1986 New York Mets Team Signed Baseball 28 Sigs With Gary Carter
Almost Gone!
$205.99
$228.99
Sale
Gary Carter PSA DNA Autograph National League Signed Baseball
Almost Gone!
$327.99
$363.99
Sale
Gary Carter God Bless 1986 Wsc Mets Expos Hof Signed Auto Vintage Baseball Jsa
Almost Gone!
$339.99
$377.99
Sale
GARY CARTER NY Mets SIGNED Rawlings OML Baseball TriStar COA
Almost Gone!
$479.99
$532.99
Sale
1987 New York Mets Team Signed National League Baseball Gary Carter PSA DNA COA
Almost Gone!
$399.99
$443.99
Sale
1980's New York Mets Team Signed National League Baseball With Gary Carter
Almost Gone!
$1,652.99
$1,836.99
Sale
Gary Carter 80-81-82 Signed Gold Glove Logo Baseball JSA
Almost Gone!
$172.99
$191.99
Sale
Gary Carter Mets/expos Signed Auto N.l. Baseball Beckett Auth
Almost Gone!
$571.99
$635.99
Sale
Gary Carter Expos Mets Hof Near Rookie Signed Auto Feeney Onl Gu'ed Baseball Jsa
Almost Gone!
$399.99
$443.99
Sale
1985 - 1986 New York Mets Team Signed Baseball 28 Sigs With Gary Carter
Almost Gone!
$207.99
$230.99
Sale
Vintage Gary Carter signed Rawlings National League baseball-BAS AB96402
Almost Gone!
$399.99
$443.99
Sale
1985 - 1986 New York Mets Team Signed Baseball 28 Sigs With Gary Carter
Almost Gone!
$463.99
$514.99
Sale
1985 New York Mets Team Signed National League Baseball Gary Carter JSA COA
Almost Gone!
$1,041.99
$1,157.99
Sale
1986 New York Mets Team Autographed Official NL Baseball With 29 Signatures Including Gary Carter PSA/DNA #W03524
Almost Gone!
$1,041.99
$1,157.99
Sale
1986 New York Mets Team Autographed Official NL Baseball With 29 Signatures Including Gary Carter PSA/DNA #W03525
Almost Gone!
$218.99
$242.99
Sale
Gary Carter PSA DNA Autograph National League Feeney Signed Baseball
Almost Gone!
$399.99
$443.99
Sale
1985 - 1986 New York Mets Team Signed Baseball 28 Sigs With Gary Carter
Almost Gone!
$159.99
$177.99
Sale
Gary Carter JSA COA Autograph Major League Signed Baseball
Almost Gone!
$399.99
$443.99
Sale
1985 - 1986 New York Mets Team Signed Baseball 28 Sigs With Gary Carter
Almost Gone!
$405.99
$450.99
Sale
Gary Carter The Kid JSA Coa Autograph National League ONL Signed Baseball
Almost Gone!
$257.99
$286.99
Sale
Signed Gary Carter Baseball - 1983 All Star Game PSA DNA
Almost Gone!
$1,652.99
$1,836.99
Sale
Gary Carter Signed 1984 All Star Game Logo Baseball MLB Holo (MVP)
Almost Gone!
$959.99
$1,066.99
Sale
Gary Carter "The Kid" Signed Major League Baseball PSA DNA Graded 10 GEM MINT
Almost Gone!
$152.99
$169.99
Sale
Gary Carter Expos Mets Dodgers HOFer SIGNED Official MLB Baseball w/ hologram
Almost Gone!
$399.99
$443.99
Sale
1988 New York Mets Team Signed National League Baseball With Gary Carter
Almost Gone!
$399.99
$443.99
Sale
1987 New York Mets Team Signed National League Baseball Gary Carter JSA COA
Almost Gone!
$276.99
$307.99
Sale
1987 NY Mets Team signed baseball 30 auto Gary Carter Strawberry Gooden CBM COA
Almost Gone!
$2,470.99
$2,744.99
Sale
Gary Carter HOF 2003 Signed Stat Baseball PSA/DNA Holo RJ Holo
Almost Gone!
$180.99
$200.99
Sale
Gary Carter Signed Newspaper Gary's Game 10/15/86 Daily News Baseball Auto PSA
Almost Gone!
$198.99
$220.99
Sale
Gary Carter PSA DNA Autographed National League Signed Baseball
Almost Gone!
$334.99
$371.99
Sale
Autographed Gary Carter Baseball - 1988 Old Timers ONL robinson Boudreau 24
Almost Gone!
$319.99
$354.99
Sale
1980's New York Mets Team Signed Baseball Gary Carter Gooden Strawberry
Almost Gone!
$338.99
$376.99
Sale
Gary Carter Signed Autographed NL Baseball Expos Mets "To Betty" COA
Almost Gone!
$399.99
$443.99
Sale
1985 - 1986 New York Mets Team Signed Baseball 28 Sigs With Gary Carter
Almost Gone!
$399.99
$443.99
Sale
1985 - 1986 New York Mets Team Signed Baseball 28 Sigs With Gary Carter
Almost Gone!
$399.99
$443.99
Sale
1987 New York Mets Team Signed National League Baseball Gary Carter JSA COA
Almost Gone!
$2,875.99
$3,195.99
Sale
Gary Carter Full Stat Signed RJ Baseball PSA/DNA
Almost Gone!
$399.99
$443.99
Sale
1985 - 1986 New York Mets Team Signed Baseball 28 Sigs With Gary Carter
Almost Gone!
$201.99
$223.99
Sale
Gary Carter Mets/expos Signed Auto N.l. Baseball Beckett Auth
Almost Gone!
$2,403.99
$2,670.99
Sale
Gary Carter Signed Heavily Inscribed STAT Major League Baseball Beckett & RJ COA
Almost Gone!
$187.99
$208.99
Sale
Gary Carter JSA Coa Autograph Major League OML Signed Baseball
Almost Gone!
$183.99
$203.99
Sale
Gary Carter JSA Coa Autograph MacPhail American League Signed BasebaLL
Almost Gone!
$399.99
$443.99
Sale
1985 - 1986 New York Mets Team Signed Baseball 28 Sigs With Gary Carter
Almost Gone!
$481.99
$534.99
Sale
Gary Carter Signed Official NL Baseball Mets Expos #8 Auto PSA COA HOF Catcher
Almost Gone!
$276.99
$307.99
Sale
Gary Carter Gem Mint 10 PSA DNA Autograph Major League Signed Baseball
Almost Gone!
$571.99
$635.99
Sale
Gary Carter Expos Mets Hof Near Rookie Signed Auto Feeney Onl Gu'ed Baseball Jsa
Almost Gone!
$573.99
$637.99
Sale
GARY CARTER Signed #8 Official MLB Baseball-HOF-EXPOS-NEW YORK METS-JSA
Almost Gone!
$399.99
$443.99
Sale
1985 - 1986 New York Mets Team Signed Baseball 28 Sigs With Gary Carter
Almost Gone!
$190.99
$211.99
Sale
2006 Futures All Star Game Team Signed Baseball Gary Carter MLB Authentic
Almost Gone!
$238.99
$264.99
Sale
Gary Carter Signed Official National League Baseball JSA COA
Almost Gone!
$399.99
$443.99
Sale
1988 New York Mets Team Signed National League Baseball With Gary Carter
Almost Gone!
$399.99
$443.99
Sale
1985 - 1986 New York Mets Team Signed Baseball 28 Sigs With Gary Carter
Almost Gone!
$201.99
$223.99
Sale
Gary Carter Steiner Coa Autograph Major League Signed Baseball
Almost Gone!
$100.99
$111.99
Sale
Darryl Strawberry "gary Carter Was Always A Kid At Heart" Signed M.l. Baseball B
Almost Gone!
$625.99
$694.99
Sale
GARY CARTER MIKE PIAZZA HOF +28 Signed Auto 2001 NY Mets NL Baseball JSA LOA
Almost Gone!
$317.99
$352.99
Sale
Lou Brock Gary Carter Garvey Feller HOF 10 auto Signed ONL Feeney Baseball COA
Almost Gone!
$653.99
$726.99
Sale
1975 NL All-Stars Team-Signed Baseball (29) Gary Carter, Tom Seaver, etc. – COA JSA
  • 1
  • 1 of 1

Collectible Gary Carter New York Mets Baseballs

Steiner Sports carries an unbeatable selection of signed Mets Gary Carter baseballs to add to your official MLB collection. Browse from our assortment of authentic Gary Carter New York Mets baseballs signed by your favorite top players. An autographed Mets Gary Carter baseball is the perfect addition to any major fan's collection and also make amazing gifts. Shop with us today at Steiner Sports to find all the best, officially licensed Gary Carter New York Mets collectibles and memorabilia.