Ends Thursday at 11:59 PM ET
Save Up To 50% Off Sitewide + Free Shipping On Orders Over $49.
1 - 72 of 134
Your Search
134 Items
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$169.99 with codeRegular: $199.99You Save: $30.00

Gary Sheffield New York Yankees Autographed Blonde Rawlings Pro Bat

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$76.49 with codeRegular: $89.99You Save: $13.50

Gary Sheffield New York Yankees Autographed 8" x 10" Hitting Photograph

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$84.99 with codeRegular: $99.99You Save: $15.00

Gary Sheffield New York Yankees Autographed 16" x 20" Hitting Photograph

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$67.99 with codeRegular: $79.99You Save: $12.00

Gary Sheffield Autographed Baseball

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$160.64 with codeRegular: $188.99You Save: $28.35

Gary Sheffield Autographed Bat - Rawling Black Pro Model JSA

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$41.64 with codeRegular: $48.99You Save: $7.35

Gary Sheffield Autographed 2007 Topps Card

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
Almost Gone!
$39.94 with codeRegular: $46.99You Save: $7.05

Gary Sheffield & Fred McGriff Autographed Gateway First Day Cover

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$96.04 with codeRegular: $112.99You Save: $16.95

Gary Sheffield Signed Baseball Steiner Certified Authentic Autograph

Almost Gone!
$30.59 with codeRegular: $35.99You Save: $5.40

Gary Sheffield Signed Photograph - Milwaukee Brewers 8x10

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$46.74 with codeRegular: $54.99You Save: $8.25

Autographed Sheffield Photograph - 8x10

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$43.34 with codeRegular: $50.99You Save: $7.65

Autographed Sheffield Photo - 8x10 W coa

Almost Gone!
$30.59 with codeRegular: $35.99You Save: $5.40

Gary Sheffield Milwaukee Brewers "rc Graph" Signed Autographed 8x10 Ph

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$45.04 with codeRegular: $52.99You Save: $7.95

Signed Gary Sheffield Photo - 8x10 W coa

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$46.74 with codeRegular: $54.99You Save: $8.25

Signed Sheffield Photo - 8x10

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$62.04 with codeRegular: $72.99You Save: $10.95

Gary Sheffield Autographed Photo - 8 X10

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$62.89 with codeRegular: $73.99You Save: $11.10

Lot of (99) 1989 Topps Gary Sheffield Rookies #343 BV $148

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$72.24 with codeRegular: $84.99You Save: $12.75

Autographed Gary Sheffield Baseball - Oml Fanatics & #R0009821

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$55.24 with codeRegular: $64.99You Save: $9.75

Gary Sheffield Autographed Ball - Official Major League

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$160.64 with codeRegular: $188.99You Save: $28.35

Signed Gary Sheffield Baseball Bat - Rawlings Pro Model JSA

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$96.04 with codeRegular: $112.99You Save: $16.95

Gary Sheffield Autographed Jersey - Blue PSA)

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.69 with codeRegular: $81.99You Save: $12.30

Signed Gary Sheffield Ball - OMLB Official BAS BECKETT F24372

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$301.74 with codeRegular: $354.99You Save: $53.25

Signed Gary Sheffield Jersey - 1992 Game Model JSA COA

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$906.94 with codeRegular: $1,066.99You Save: $160.05

Gary Sheffield 2003 All Star Game Signed Game Used Jersey With JSA & Mears COA

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$92.64 with codeRegular: $108.99You Save: $16.35

Gary Sheffield Signed Ball - Sheff Steiner COA

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$43.34 with codeRegular: $50.99You Save: $7.65

Gary Sheffield Autographed Photo - 1992 Upper Deck Print 8x10 COA

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$72.24 with codeRegular: $84.99You Save: $12.75

Autographed Gary Sheffield Ball - LA Souvenir Full Size Helmet JSA CO

Almost Gone!
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
Almost Gone!
$30.59 with codeRegular: $35.99You Save: $5.40

Gary Sheffield Autographed Photo - 8x10 AWM COA

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$50.99 with codeRegular: $59.99You Save: $9.00

Gary Sheffield Brewers Signed 1992 Upper Deck Card #234 Beckett 148170

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$63.74 with codeRegular: $74.99You Save: $11.25

Autographed Gary Sheffield Baseball - Marlins Mini Helmet JSA COA)

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$86.69 with codeRegular: $101.99You Save: $15.30

Gary Sheffield Milwaukee Brewers 1989 Fleer Signed Auto Card BAS

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$154.69 with codeRegular: $181.99You Save: $27.30

Autographed Gary Sheffield Jersey - HOLOGRAM

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$90.09 with codeRegular: $105.99You Save: $15.90

Gary Sheffield

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$139.39 with codeRegular: $163.99You Save: $24.60

Signed Gary Sheffield Ball - # 10 500 Hr Club 2009 Inaugural Jsa

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$171.69 with codeRegular: $201.99You Save: $30.30

Gary Sheffield Autographed Baseball Bat - Rawlings PSA DNA Certified

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$162.34 with codeRegular: $190.99You Save: $28.65

Autographed Gary Sheffield Ball - #10 Tigers Marlins Single Mint Jsa Petco

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.69 with codeRegular: $81.99You Save: $12.30

Signed Gary Sheffield Baseball - OMLB Official BAS BECKETT F24369

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$185.29 with codeRegular: $217.99You Save: $32.70

Gary Sheffield Autographed Bat (500 Hr Club) W/ Proof!

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$185.29 with codeRegular: $217.99You Save: $32.70

Gary Sheffield Autographed Bat (500 Hr Club) W/ Proof!

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
Almost Gone!
$38.24 with codeRegular: $44.99You Save: $6.75

Autographed Gary Sheffield Picture - 8x10 Image 1 67)

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$77.34 with codeRegular: $90.99You Save: $13.65

Gary Sheffield Autographed Photograph - 8x10 Image #1 Matted & Framed

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$124.94 with codeRegular: $146.99You Save: $22.05

Autographed Sheffield Photograph - 8x10 JSA 144617

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$185.29 with codeRegular: $217.99You Save: $32.70

Gary Sheffield Autographed Bat (500 Hr Club) W/ Proof!

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$185.29 with codeRegular: $217.99You Save: $32.70

Gary Sheffield Autographed Bat (500 Hr Club) W/ Proof!

Almost Gone!
$18.69 with codeRegular: $21.99You Save: $3.30

Gary Sheffield Signed Picture - 8 5x11

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$330.64 with codeRegular: $388.99You Save: $58.35

Autographed Gary Sheffield Baseball Bat - 2006 SAM PSA DNA G45226

Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$62.04 with codeRegular: $72.99You Save: $10.95

Gary Sheffield Autographed Ball - Dodgers M l W coa